The Archive · 1932

SPONSORSHIP

1 May 23. "here can be no great surprise that the discussions which have been proceeding among certain bodies of representative foreign opinion on the subject of the Shanghai problem have obtained publicity and notice in the Chinese press. It would be absurd to. mai lit to express: or attempt to formulate their opinions on this subject. It is equally absurd to put forward the view that such discussion: to quote from the words of eritfe, can be dismissed in these rin Adventurous foreigners have come to our country. They have solicited "our trades. They in' the

country, and enjoying rights ud, living on, the fat of out Drivileyen they never dreamt of ketting And now, in insatiable greed, they desire' to further' establish their firm foot-hold here by agitatings the demilitarisation—of Shangha As this journal has pointed out, the idea of holding a Round Table Conference is not in itself Yeprehensible or necessarily neglectful of Chinese interest The question to consider whether the holding of such a conference is immediately fes sible. Shanghai can hardly be considered as a problem apart, It is closely wrapped up in the general integration and administrative stagnation China as a whole, The disabilities under which Shanghai ouffers cannot be removed e3 cept by consideration of their main cause, The weakness of ithe recognised government of China is its present lack of control over a very large section of the country. Moreover, taking the recent, happenings here into account, it must be admitted that they are intimal Jof Chinese administration. It is not surprising, therefore, that the Chinese should regard the Proposal as a not very effectively camouflaged version of a scheme which. was put forward lunguardedly from Tokyo at a time when it was believed that the armed argument would be successfully applied to Shang-ai. It is human to err, and criticism of those who so gravely misinterpreted the issues involve led in Japanese action in January last should not be pressed too far. But it cannot be denied that, if an error has been made, it is not possible successfully to build, on the basis of that error, a scheme for the eventual restoration of Shanghai's integrity. In these columns apprehension has constantly been expressed at the attitude which too large a section of the foreign community here have [been inclined to take in regard to recent happenings. It is not. unfair to say that the events of the last. fortnight must have. greatly shaken the confidence of those who have been persistent jin' the maintenance of that attitude. It is not sufficient to Jconsider the damage done to [Shanghai's integrity by the deliberate or involuntary mistakes of Chinese administration Hwithout taking also into account ithe basic fact that that integrity has been assailed by the ill-advised action of one of the foreign partners in the Settlement. Non-recognition of the lundesirability of building up a safer Shanghai, on the basis of Japanese action or the support fof Japanese bayonets, is little distinguishable from the advo-leach of schemes which, though excellent in themselves, are not p accompanied by clear con-Jdemnation of the measures which ave inflicted much suffering on ind presented undoubted grievances to the Chinese community. There can be no denial of the fact that it is as much in the interests of the Chinese as of the foreigner that Shanghai's restoration and, indeed, endowment with a surer quality of integrity should be attempted. But as everyone has agreed that. such an attempt cannot be made except with Chinese consent and [Chinese cooperation, it is essential that an effort' should be made to convince the Chinese that there has been a radical revision of previously expressed opinions on this subject. It may be contended that the Shanghai Municipal Council and the Spenks," is even more definite: would be wide of the mark to say that any of the powers as such has encouraged Japan. Tauneh the military. intervention at Shanghai. But it certainly trae that the foreigners, especial ly foreign business interests, in Shanghai, are' at heart" in sympathy with the measures taken by the Japanese. There area number of reasons why they should welcome Japanese intervention. In the first place, they want to" bolster "up" the International Settlement and the French Concession whose. status has, inthe face of Nationalist onslaughts, been growing more and more uncertain.

Unless ostriches have found a resting place in the foreign camp to the domination of expressions of opinion there, the accuracy of these dicta cannot be gain said. Yet it is equally certain that there has been a [great revision of opinion, in the last two or three weeks at all events. The need is to get that revision across, and it is to be hoped that the controversy now Jawakened by an incomplete revelation of a purely—sectional foreign attitude will be as promptly turned into {the safer channel of friendly and frank discussion and a more definite recognition by foreigners lof the realities of the Chinese view of the Shanghai situation. Tf it be contended that any Chinese opinion can be nothing but intransigeant, then a defeatist attitude is' inevitable. A demand for a Round Table Coi ference will be put up and its only value will lie in the fact that, at some future date, when more troubles have come upon Shanghai, the promoters will the doubtful satisfaction of being able to say that they made leonerete suggestions for avoid-lance of these troubles. Even if they could say that, would be very doubtful whether they would be upheld by the logie of events. Most sensible people will agree that a policy lof drift should be avoided. But fa policy of precipitate formal: tion of demands on the basis of a one-sided assessment of the factors of the problem is even more dangerous, because it simply encour Imoge arduous, but more effect of feeling the way, of getting into touch, informally otherwise, with Chinese. opinion, of interchanging views: land of attempting to arrive at general formula by which al [who, taking advantage of the in-levirable economic collapse, could precipitate a revolution, ' There may be for the moment an un-Iholy bond between the militarists and the extreme radicals in the assault on capitalist influences. Sooner or later it must} be dissolved and the dissolution would imperil the whole fabric lof the present Constitution, lowing to the disappearance of {the experience and principles of those who have guided Japan lalang her rapid path to modern civilisation.

Desperate situations require desperate remedies. The musti-Jness of the tag is not necessarily fa proof of its unwisdom. Japan should have the right to work out ther own destiny. In this world to-day the process has not the rigidly exclusive qualities of bygone eras. The interdependlence of nations, to which Japan herself has been an earnest wit-Mess by her comradeship with ithe West, renders it impossible for isolated action to be taken with consequences limited to its immediate scope. Thu: last few months, the rumbling of the storm, which has now broken over Japan, precipitated grave issues' in Manchuria and Shanghai. It would be impossible to say that the Japanese [Government showed itself' able to direct its handling of those issues, without abdicating much lof its' authority to the General Staffs. Its representatives Geneva and in world-capitals were in the uncomfortable position of being unaware of the exact intentions of the Government for which they spoke. The reason was clear: that Government was attempting to ride on ithe snaffle because it dare not use the curb. And the snaffle has been only partially compet-lent to keep the Government in ithe saddle, Now it seems in danger of having given way altogether.

Outwardly the fight is for the control of national policy. Act ually it is for the soul of Japan.

despairing attempt to revert to the Middle Ages, when the whole [system of a modern world stands firm opposition to the doc trines applied, can be made only at the cost of inviting a terrible and inevitable revulsion.

The nations today are, it is true, muttering gloomily word They are not prepared without a struggle to be engulfed by its reality.

There is no reason believe that the struggle can: cannot be preserved or inspired shackling it in the chains of a-discredited servitude,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account