The Archive · 1933

Negotiation Difficulties

To the Editor of the "NontH-Cnina Datty New:

Si,—The opinions expressed through your columns of the, last few days on the aublect of direct negotiations are of special interest contrast the nationalism as it exists in China with tha Japan. From the country which is the wronged party, under whatever precept vou prefer, which is receiv. ing all" the injuries, we have "Y,8.7." who asks. for' moral cou ase from the leaders for, the ne for w settlement at a sacr fice, and "E.D2." who thinks that no true man in China will desire to} negotiate with Japan under the pre.

elreumstances and that it would be a great dishonour to all of us, but_who nevertheless appeals. that and national 4ifferenees be forgotten in a spirit of brotherly, ce-operation, "From the wrong doing party, th inflicting the inj "Yoshitaka" who is satisfied th Japan is "cawing her own de out of the world chaos, and, to quote from the previous one of his correspondences, regardless" of japan will gw abend in the steady performance of her mission in. Man churins, s What' China has to do will the in the early: recognition of grim realltien...cof the futility' of -ber farther resistance to Japan..."

[do not entertain a _thoment's doubt, over the patriotic sentiments} of cither of these' Chinese correspon. dences; that these sentiments lack the vehemence" which Westerners would expect is "a trait that is inborn to us all alike, And F am forced to believe that."*Yashitaka's"

florification of. Might as an Ideal has the supper of the bulk: of the If those who are ava: from the influence of. intoxicating enthusiasm for national: agrandisement are-not able to see. or lack the courage to frankly: express on,{! an-issue where the plainness of right or-wrong has no parallel in the whole history: of civilised. world, po better be digiihisioned about those liberal-minded Japanese!

"have been threatened or coer~ teed into silence, and "F.D.Z." come down from "his flight of logie into azure heaven, where no human. reed, revenge or hatred can exist.'

'As'a realist in the cruelest sense of the word T would rather look Heability and feasibility. "With the this subject from' the point of prae-

"grim realities" before us, we are hot privileged as the League and the other, Powers to' decupy ourselves:

ith delays, evasions and hypocei sies for the' sake of "save-face, negotiation for settlement at a sacrifice would bring us and the; world anywhere, let it be, dishonfur or no dishonour But Japan has made up her mind to funt her mission. to carve out her destiny. "Japanese militarism' is na' codnterpat of the old,. are rogant neber alles. Deutsche. kuli tur"s-but, in the next breath If ix: "Japan is. unturfing the: banner of lofty' idealism called. Waugtao.", maybe, excused "if I. should "ack-knowledge just.as~ much -authdrity from -Geneval "Araki as from "Yo shitaka," if. should have more, respect' for the General's Huang-tao, translated by Journal ax Imperial Principle," than to the!

Manchukuo" Premier's: Wang-tao, For, after all, who rules: Japan or Manchuria?

Under the banner of Araki's Huang-tao, Asia is to be placed, willy-nilly, under the rule of Japa and Japan to be prepared for eri ses in India and elsewhere and for the punishment of the Whites for their impudence. Huang-tao or ug-tao, ax long as it is on the principle that "Might is often pelled to be right," what difference pos oes it make?

With the determination of the Wang-taoists or Huang-taoists, with, their growing appetite," on what terms are We to negotiate?" How! much* must' we be prepared to sacrifice? And, after all our sacrifices,. we shall be safely bound to. continue in our unpreparedness; but jean we prevent Japan from taking Such swetions ax" she deems neces: sary? LO. international treaties and avowals cannot bind her, what can? Have not her assurances, since and before the crisis, made tis quite sceptic? Couldn't she by the simplest of methods create "new situations" to make past—of tions obsolete? Couldn't pretext! found, made, or simply claimed"

All these questions must be first inwered before we would dose to embark on negotiation, At Mukden, according to Lytton' Report, "negotiations were progressing favourably." At Shinghai, we accepted all demands and. according to League Report, "the Chinese troops would not have time to with. draw even had they wished to do:

Chivichow and "Shanhaikua Teil wu easy preys because the Japfanese told us that they would re-Hard any movement of troops as Whether the atulenmte is to per-slut, whether the, undeclared war tobe' continued "with. renewed in tensity, it does not depend on China ud as'Japan ix bent. straight ahead without looking to the right or left, all Ras to. depend on whether foreljen interests will be ficiently endangered to. Invlice heutrale to mediate and intervene.

Shanghai. for the cause of humanity.

Ag far as we are concerned, there is nothing left for us but to" make further "conquests. for Japan as diffeult as "possible, so as not to encourage her appetite, not "necessarily @ fight unto death, nor even for the hope of success. This is not irresponsibility; It is a shameless suinson of impotence!

tenour and prestige are luxuries indulged" in only' by' thave whose superior equipment for destruction enable them to give free reign to their caprices: they are pretexts for action reserved for the Shanghai, Am 8, 1983.

The Commons Debate To the Editor of the "Noatx-Cuina Dairy News.

Stn,—With deep interest I have read "the historic debate of the Hansard as transcribed. in your journal of recent date,_ which led me to an inevitable conclusion that after all. there was probably something of imbroglio was dealt in Geneva, and

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account