The Archive · 1932

A Dead Snail

Judicial tribunals have a well-merited reputation for being able, exactly and decorously, to describe even the most inde-cerous object. The House of Lords recently had to deal with avery humble minister to huraan refreshment and it was described in the following terms:

The bottle was... of dark opaque glass, so that the condition of its contents could not be as-retained "by. inspection, a closed with metal cap, while on the side was a label bearing' the name of the respondent, Ju plain, blunt English this was a bottle of ginger beer into which by some unexplained accident a dead snail had intruded, A Scottish shopgirl had purchased the bottle of winger beer, but, owing to the opacity of the glass, she did not" see the Snail: Although the law report does not suggest that she drank out of the bottle, that practice ix not unknown even among the ndueted picnic par-rate she stated that owing to the additional luxury provided she. be came seriously ill, in spite of her Failure to drink the whole of the contents, 'The ginger heer manu-Tacturer' was asked by legal process to sive the lady £500 as damages for his negligence The case went through the} ottish courts—against the lady and, finally, reached the House of Lords Where, even then, unanimity of judyment could not be secured on the Bench, How ever, by a majority of three to two''the lady w Lord Atkin expressing the view that " more important problem—had nev occupied their Lordships in a judicial capacity because of its bearing on the public health and Deeause of its test oF the system of law under which it arose, the Jaw of Scotland and England being identical for once on that particular point. So a dead); snail, after xravely perturbing the legal machinery of the Scottish courts, actually stirred. up the whole majesty. of the judicial bench of the House of Lords. The important principle involved was the protection of the poisoned consumer against a agent manufacturer, Lord Atkin, whose judgment was taken' as standing for the prevailing majority. view, pointed out that the rule of law neces: sarily Himited the range of complainants and the extent of the remedy, He took for his example the golden rule which, in law, was a question not of loving but of not injuring one's neighbour, and the lawyers would also further restrict the issue seeking a definition of the word "neighbour." In the case of a manufacturer who put up food in a container which must be opened by a consumer without preliminary inspection, negli-Hence ought not to xo wa punish: ed, otherwise the law would be aravely defective If the Scottish courts which had rejected the unfortunate shopgirl's. complaint were upheld, then no remedy would exist for the consumer who was injured by, drinking bottled beer or eating poisoned food. Moreover, the user of what ought to be w harmless proprietary me cine, stich us an ointment, or soap, or cleaning fluid, would be similarly unprotected. Leaving, out of the question whether a snail—alive or dead—is or is not harmful in the physical ax distinct from the—metaphysical sense, to. the layman it must seem extraordinary that a case of this kind has to run such an elaborate gauntlet of legal lear ing to find a decision in accor ance with law and commonsense. Eyem then it will have been noted that exceedingly able judges like Lord Buckmaster, a ex-Lord Chancellor, and Lord Tomlin, disagreed on the basis of case and common law. The man will, therefore, be glad that, by a' majority, eommonsense won the day. For, after it is a little hard to have to risk the introduction of a snail into the usually harmless bottle uingerbeer. Let not the adents of the more vigorous liquid think that this serves the] drinker of soft drinks right," because they would be equally exposed to danger if the dead snail had not come to their rescue. What, for example, could be worse than finding: [spiders in one's beer? Indeed beer drinkers as a class should welcome this decision in favour! of the humbler liquid, because now surely they have a legal Fight to call to account the miscreants who make beer that is: not beer at all but painfully watered-down swipes!

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account