It was inevitable that the publication by the Shanghai Municipal Council of the estimates for the Orchestra for the coming financial year should attract attention. It is expected that this year much ink will be spilled before the matter comes before the annual meeting of ratepayers who will have to decide, what shall be done about it. In this connection it should be emphasized that the letter by Economy appearing in these columns on Sunday is based upon a misapprehension, He appears to assume that the Council has appropriated approximately $200,000 for the upkeep of the Orchestra for the next twelve months. It has, in fact, done nothing of the sort: it has merely put forward the estimated cost of maintenance leaving the ultimate decision as to what shall be done in the hands of the ratepayers themselves, who are by no means committed to any of the estimates which the Council presents annually until they have voted upon them. In order that readers may have the facts clearly before them, it is necessary that the whole question should be reviewed as briefly as possible. Four determined attempts have been made, in 1923, 1927, 1934 and 1935 either to abolish the Municipal Orchestra or to alter its complexion by handing over responsibility fór its control to another body. In June 1935 the Council requested the Orchestra and Band Committee to investigate the possibilities of reorganizing the Orchestra on more economical lines and to give consideration to the question of the desirability of retaining the Orchestra as then constituted. The Committee eventually came to the conclusion that an annual saving of $78,000, cquld be made, reducing the cost of the Orchestra to under $200,000 by terminating then existing contracts with musicians many of whom participated in the privileges of the Council Administrative staff, and re engaging upon appropriately graded salaries under contracts of one year's duration such musicians as desired to recuter the Council's service.
In order to leave the new proposal fairly and squarely before the ratepayers the Budget for 1936 contained no provision for. the Orchestra and the whole question was left in such a manner that an amendment to the Budget, proposed by a ratepayer and seconded by another was the only method by which the orchestra could be retained. An amendment to the Budget providing for the necessary $200,000 was duly proposed, seconded and carried by a large majority. Proposing the amendment, the Rev. C. L. Boynton reduced the problem concerning the retention of the Orchestra to three main questions:
(a) Is the Municipal Council at any time justified in maintaining any kind of orchestra at public expense (b) If so, on what grounds is that expense justified at the present time? (c) What kind of Orchestra is justifiable in times like these After answering those questions the proposer went on to contend that the maintenance of the Orchestra involved the expenditure of less than one per cent. of the then current budget; the abolition of the orchestra would create a new economic problem of unemployment, while its retention would mean the continuance of the provision of a cultural facility which is considered in all civilized places worthy of support. The same questions and the same contentions apply with equal force to-day, though the circumstances are very changed from 1936. The question, therefore, which the ratepayers, and not the Council, will have t9 decide is whether the circumstances are so much changed that a reversal of the policy then decided upon has become imperative. Any two ratepayers can propose and second an amendment to the Budget proposing the deletion of the estimates for the Orchestra and'the question would then be for the annual meeting to decide. The Council is committed to nothing and the ultimate fate of the Orchestra is in the hands of those who have to pay the bill.
It is to.be expected that the usual arguments for and against retention of the Orchestra will be freely adduced, but the only real question for consideration is as to whether the serious reverses which Shanghai has suffered as a result of Sino-Japanese hostilities have brought about a situation in which the continuance of the Orchestra or any other similar luxury for that matter becomes completely inexcusable, Doubtless there will be some who would like to receive some guidance in the matter from the Municipal Council. On the face of it it would not appear to be very extravagant to continue spending one per cent, of the Budget outlay on so excellent an undertaking as the aggregation of talent which plays under the baton of M. Paci. Yetif it is, in the circumstances, a gross extravagance, might not other expenditures be considered in the same light? It is the devout hope of most Shanghailanders that the difficult times through which the city is passing will have but a temporary effect upon its fortunes, and that gloomy as the outlook appears to be now, brighter days are ahead. Those who feel that way will undoubtedly stress the finality of any decision to do away with the Orchestra, pointing out that once these talented men are dispersed it will be very difficult to build up another orchestra, and, possibly, also very expensive. No one would dream for one instant of doing away with the parks. Yet they are luxuries, too, more extensively patronized and fulfilling a more necessary mission. Their cost to the ratepayers in 1936 was $308,000 net, again another small sum compared with the total Budget. The support given to the Municipal Orchestra by this journal is no different this year from what it has been when controversy concerning it has raged in the past. Itis'true that the times are more serious than they have ever been before, but the decision which the ratepayers will have to reach is as to whether they are so desperate that the comparatively small expenditure which the Orchestra involves, would, if it were saved, be. any real contribution to the fortunes of the city.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.