The Archive · 1932

JAPAN'S OBSERVATIONS

Declaring that general recogni. tion of Manchitkuo and general ce-operation in its development form ithe only means of stabilizing conditions in Manchuria and the Far st, the Japanese Government Janswers many points of criticism in Jo lengthy series of observations on the Lytton Report, the Englis summary of which was issue simultaneously in Geneva and Tokyo yesterday Japan defendsTher action Manchuria, stating that any other [country pieced in her position would have come to the same conclusion Jand followed the same course, The Lytton Commission's suggestions for a solution come. in. for much comment, Japan considering that they would amount in practice ta a disguised international control Jot Manchuria' and could be acceptable either to Manchukuo or "Too refined and intrijeate and" not - adaptable to the realities of the Far joomment on the sug anced by the Commission. the introduction to the observations the Japanese Government ex-Presses sincere appreciation of the endeavours made by the members of the Commission, but declares that owing to the shortness of time available the Commission could only quire a superficial impression.

felt that if the Commission had sited other parts of the country, especially 'South China, their opin: fon regarding the Chinese situation would" have been' considerable modified.

What is described as the icellaneous evidence" on wi Report is based is criticised jing, used invariably. against Japan leading in one case to" a complete misconstruction of the—motives. which actuated the Japanese armed forces, "and in the other" to the presentation of suggestions for. the fature government of Manchukuo which are consistent neither with the tenor of the remainder of the Report nor with the realities of the a situation."

The document then proceeds to examine the Report minutely an-sworing contestable points to Japan, The thesis that "China is not organised state" is developed and the observations proceed to sketch conditions in the country, Emphasis is laid on anti-foreign activities fostered by the National Government leading to "fifty millions of young Chinese growing up under the influence of violent ideals constituting a terrific problem for the future" Reference is made to bay-scotts, and revolutionary diplomacy. The "abnormal status of foreigners: in China" is mentioned and the consequent inapplicability of normal peace machinery.

The chapter on Manchuria re-irks on the failure of the Com-

Japan's. Jand achievements in port greatly criticised. After Jing with the September 18 at some Nength the chapter concludes by the in short, the whole series of operations were entailed by the put ting into execution of a plan care: fully prepared to meet the alarming, eventuality of a Chinese. attack They had. no relation to anything but self-defence, and the Japanese Government cannot.: allow, either their necessity or their appropriateness to be the subject of diszus-

Much attention is paid to the new state of Manchukuo and the state: ment "that the present regime. is Met the outcome. of a spontaneous movement. Considerable argu Iment is put forward in support of Ithe Japanese contention. The con-delusion is reached:

"To deny that the present regime is to be regarded as the outcome of natural and. spontaneous move-tment, is to admit that all the evi-Jdence presented by Manchukuo has been disregarded, including the "Histoire de L'independence clu Mandchoukuo" with its detailed and specific account of the many demon-Istrations which have set the seal of {their approval upon the new gov-Jernment. It is repeated confidently that the movement was a genuine, spontaneous, peculiar and natural At length, Japan's observations set forth in the conclusions which follow in full:

The following propositions have now been advanced: dition. of confusion bordering upon anarchy, and remains in the same condition at the present moments that so long as such state of affairs China may properly considered as in a condition of na. tional disintegration, and that at least under present circumstances it entirely impossible to tell' when China may come to have a strong and permanent central government, even if we geant the ultimate possibility.of that event, "That, becauso.of the fact that sucha state of affairs prevails in China, foreign-Tives and property jean not be afforded adequate protection, and that especially in recent cation of internal conflict operation of the so-called "revolutionary" foreign policy of the Kuomintang directed against foreign Powers.

3. That consequently foreign Powers have continued to exercise exceptional powers and privileges fu. China of a character, now without parallel elsewhere in the world, such as extraterritorial jurisdiction, settlements and con-ossians, the maintenance of a sons and the permanent stationing, of warships in inland waters, That while all foreign Powers having interests in China have tered from the anarchical. condition and antiforeign policy of China, Japan has suffered, by far the most severely.

5. That Japan stands in the most intimate Telation, geographic ally and historically, to Manchin that she possesses in. that important treaty rights beside economic Interests, while great numbers of her people are settled there; that, moreover, the question of her own' national security. makes Japan vitally" interested in -Manchuria both from a political and a strategic point of view:—in ting, that Japan's, position in Manchuria an altogether exceptional and cial one, unparallel in other parts of the world.

6, That of late years the former Manchurian authorities resorted to various intrigues with a view undermining this special position, and that after the. rapproachment of General Chang Hsueh-liang with the National Government the etcroachments of the Manchurian 8 upon the rights" and Interests of Japan, despite Japan's earnest efforts to ameliorate "the situation, became increasingly -fre-ind flagrant, producing an state of tension,'

7. That it was in this strained atmosphere that the events of 18 September occurred; that none of the measures. taken by the Japanese Army at the time of that inc dent, or subsequently exceeded the limits of the right. of self-defence; and that Japan must on any impar= ial consideration be pronounced to have done precisely what another Power would have done in similar circumstances.

That Manchuria has always i ly, well as georg to China" Proper, and that its inhabitants bitterly. resent: ed the tyrannous rule of. th Changs, and opposee the latter's dragged Manchuria the civil turmoil of China Prover;—that from this geographic and historical circumstance. coupled with the popular opposition to' the Chang, there sprang the movement known as "Preserve the Frontiers and Give ux Peace!"——that the foundation of Manchukuo by the spontaneous Manchurians,. with this movement, coupled with' the Manchu "Restoration Movement, as making steady progress, guid cas by, Sound policy and, hax 4 highly, promising fature before it, and finally, that the attitude of Japan towards the establishment of Manchukuo and her eventual formal recognition of that state do not violate any international engagement whatever, The fact must be thrown into relief that the Chinese problem, and especially: the Manchurian. problem, fare characterized by exceptional complexity and by abnormal features, which render it dificult to

ployed in dealing with internation! apply, the formulae commonly. em-questions under ordinary circum Stances. "Nor can the procedure employed in handling such an abnormal question, nov any solution that may. eventually be "reached, "established precedents for ordinary cases international dispute. To ite the Report, "This is not a ease "in which one country has declared war lon another country without previous:

exhausting the opportunities for jeonciliation provided in the Covenang the Leagtie of Nations, Neither

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account