Geneva, Nov. 21
The Japanese case in connection ]with the Sino-Japanese dispute over Manchuria was opened this morning by the chief Japanese delegate, Mr. Y. Matsuoka, at a meeting of the Council of the League of Ni tions "specially convened to con: der the Lytton Report. The Council Chamber was crowded for the meeting, among the spectators being. Lord Lytton and other members the Commission of Inquiry.
Mr, de Valera, the President of the Council, after a few remarks about the origin of the Lytton Report, paid a tribute to the conscientious work they had performed and said their document was an illuminating one. He thanked Lord Lytton and his colleagues for their fine work, which was a matter for congratulation and encouragement.
Mr. de Valera then reviewed the procedure in the dispute and men-form of international control im toned, the jtHoned the action of the. special action, of the any case, no such reconstruction of assembly im setting up the Com-China could be effected without a Hlong delay which it is impossible for Japan to contemplate.
'Any scheme which' would tend to destroy that condition of peace and order which: is now. in process of restoration will irresistibly usher in a new era of disputes and difficulties, Would it, not, then, be better stateostabilisation of conditions in Man-manship to Wwork at least for the Should not the world whic' has manifested so much patience Shupathy for Grenty' years it the Matsukoa to present his observations, adding that a similar opportunity would be given to the Chinese delegate at the meeting' this afternoon. Mr. Matsuoka began his speech at 11.40 a.m.
Matsuoka's. Appeal for Patience 'Mr. Matsuoka's speech followed the broad lines of the Japanese me- ed morandum on the Report, He said the Lytton Report, taken as a whole, especially in the' descriptive pas: sanes, furnished a valuable pictuve|defence, the Siete one of events and there were even whole. the Pact lof Paris was s0 explic sections with which the Japaneso|ot to" question or den iene ly understood Government was entirely in accord. [aation, The Japanese, he said, wished first Japan had not referred the ques-Jot-all to express their sineeke appre-ition of Manchuria to the Lega tion and thanks for the work of tious for the following reasons: the members of the Lytton Commise (1) National, sentment eect ass, sion. The Report, however, was not (Permit outside interference;, (2)
proper in its deductions as q fon- Because the position of Iananeee ger study would have produced, subjects in' Manchuvia would have rag, have, thero"ore, drafted cer-lor the dey fare been seriously undermined. in view consideration and hope that these in observations for the Council's Treayrag My tore riy detdetal to be fally weighed. Japan is uni situation each he azn the while Westerners were arguing the ble aimee i the Reports some: and the apanese might eave hes auditions in China. a regards clay Rove of Have had to "Coniitions in China are worse (4). When the breaking point now. he continued, Line of the Washington Conference. count, "than. at' the Jeane, chenan {hG,. breaking point There was then no. threat of Communism in China. General Chiang, He disagreed with the contention: Kai-shek is to-day fighting the Com: that Manchuria was an integral munist movement, but the National) part of China and said that none of Government and' the Kuomintang the recognised—governments of have not abandoned the principles ul ever controlled it, which caused various foreign Gov-[+ ith the Commission that lerments a few yearn ago to increase return to statue ico Was unsatisfactheir garrisons at Shanghai, tory, but he entirely disagreed thal {ho maintenance of the present. ve-Mr. Matsuoka declared that the' ime would be equally Uunsatistacrelations of China with foreign, Powers hud not improved sine radical ideas were adopted by the The establishment of the State of Kuomintang. The National Govern-Manchuluo appeared to be the only ment wa permeated "With "acute Possible solution. Hence Japanes anti-foreignism and was working recognition of it, Siduously to instil hatred of foreign-The mere consideration on our ors in the minds of the youner part of "an "alternative solution generation. might possibly, lay the whole Far Fifty million young Chinese, he Eastern: situation open to" serious said, were growing up under' the disorders, Tt would, immedi rely un-influence of violent ideas and this settle the feeling of confidence exit constituted a terrific problem for the ing in Manchukuo. "Tt would en-immediate future, courage further activities from The boycott, by which the Japan-China to create disorders.
Jere in China had been tortured for We can enter into no. stich con-many years was being utilised ax an sideration," "he emphatically. as-instrument of national policy to secure the abandonment by & foreign, Mr. Matxuoka refuted the star Power of its treaty rights. ment of the Lytton Comiissi "The Towers have outlawed, by questioning the genuineness of the treaty, resort to war with mem. 1 independence movement in. Manchu-would "ask the Council, why. should la and declared that Manchukuo did official or semi-oficial character, be Bot a boycott, when it assumed an mat ove ils organisation to Japan= initiative, but it was due to the condemned by the League and outlawed by Mr. Matsuoka disclaimed the iden; which The said was in some places latent in the Lytton Report. that Japan was bitterly hostile to. China, He said the Japanese Government believed that the Chinese people had been much misled, terrorised and misrepresented and their main) desire was to enjoy in peace the results of their industry, he went on," is maintain old friendly attitude and shes looks forward to ages of prosperous, peighbourly ce-operation between the thvo nations."
He referred to the Lytton Commission's statement that the damage done to the railway near Muicden on September 18, 1931 was insufficient to justify the military action that was taken and said the occurrence of the explosion, if taken only by itself, would have been quite insignificant, j but the Report failed to take fully into account the serious backirotind of the situation. Had the incident occurred at another period when the tension was not so great, the observations of the Commission might have been correct and justified. Japan was unable to agree to. the [Commission's finding that the Japanese military operations on the night of September 18 could not be reganlas "measures of legitimate self defence. wish of the people there to be lof Marshal Chang Heueh-1 The Commission, he said, seemed to have disregarded much informa:
supplied them on this matte He emphasised that Japanese milltary and civil officials were forbid-iden to parti ein. attempts to establish.a new political order Manchuria, He regretted that the Commission seemed to have been Persuadeyto accept statements given them by" supporters of Marshal Chang in preference to those of Manchukuo officials. stance, he mentioned the "amazinie Progress of Manchukuo," including the budgetary" situation, Referring td the existing bandi try, Mr. Matsuoka declared that the present" outlawry was being to. some extent supported from China, proper with the express purpose of, making a demonstration of diseontent before the western world, is unfair", he said, "to. make Japan responsible for what has hapened in Manchuria."
Had China asa whole, or even Manchuria alone been ' properly governed and the rights, interests and lives of the Japanese people there been free from deliberately. destructive efforts, there would have been no change, said Mr. Matsuoka. We acted ' spontanously in self-defence and when we acted the independence movement Matsuoka quoted on this! the Kellogg Note of June 23, He drew a parallel with the incident at Navarino, where a chance
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.