The Archive · 1932

ON PRINCIPLE

The wharves of the China Merchants' Steam Navigation Company have been taken over by the new management, under the Government scheme. The China Realty Company is stated to have acquiesced under protest. The Marquis Li is still in detention.. Mr. T. V. Soong has declared That the " agreement with the China Realty Company will not be recognised and that the wharves will never be allow. ed to. xo under foreign control Clarification of the issues raised by the repudiation of the contract between the Marquis: Li and the China Realty Compa has not proceeded beyond those points. It would seem that the matter is left very much in the The mere assertion that the Chinese Government does not like the agreement, ostensibly signed one of its officials, is a fragile prop for the extra-legal measures taken by the Government to enforce it.

The taciturnity. of the Government incites surmise on the possible arguments used—to justify the arbitrary detention of Marquis Li and. the virtual repudiation of its agent's signature. It might be contended, for example, that the foreign " re-who negotiated with Marquis Li and the various superintendents should have taken the fullest possible precautions to ensure that the reulations of the Chinese Government regarding such contracts were duly fulfilled. The approval of the Vice-Minister of Communications may have bound the Communications Ministry, but it—so runs the argument—eould not be stretch-fed to bind the higher Govern: ment authorities. The man tude of the sum involved and the exceptionally high rates of interest—9 per cent. at 85, according to the Marquis Li—are considered to Rave intensified the need for the most pertinacious scrutiny of the power of the Government's ostensible _representative to sign the contract. control of the China Merchants Company, exceptional vigilance was demanded. The mere fact that the Government could not have been unaware of the negotiations spread, as they were, over a period of some three or four years, is not taken to preclude the necessity for thorough ascertainment of the definite views of the highest authorities.

That seems to be a sound argument for investigation of the circumstances in which the contract, so dramatically revealed during the week-end, was completed. It does not' cov justification of the extraordinary action taken by the authorities detaining Marquis Li or seizing by virtual force the property alleged to have been transferred under that contract. If Marquis Li were considered to have failed in his duty, legal means were open for his' being produced to answer the charges in a court of law. The Government appears to have placed itself in the position of those who maintain that protection of legal rights cannot be secured from the Courts. It has also assisted to demonstrate the fact that personal liberty, within the International Settlement and the French Concession, is not_xubject to the vicissitudes of life outside. Marquis Li, after being invited to proceed. on speciously innocuous grounds, into Chinese territory, was there incontinently deprived of that personal liberty which he would still have retained, in the absence of judicial process. operating to the contrary, had hho not accepted that invitation. Similarly by repudiating the agreement and by &nforeing action contrary to its provisions, the Government has shown di dain of the facilities for correcting the errors of American subjects the United in Star It is difficult Court here. to look upon such a display of executive irresponsibility anything but a reversion to methods which the Government has strenuously endeavoured—to disown when pressing China's claim for international respect to be paid to her courts, her observance of the rule of law and her fidelity to agreements. When Mr. T. V, Soong criticises the cross mismanagement_and corruption: ampant in the China Merchants'

Steam Navigation g, Company, he commands instant sympathy. But a short cut to reform hardly lies through the draconian process of expropriation.

'The _rehabititat of China Merchants' Compa: a commercial problem. figures of the indebtedness of that organisation suggest that loan of the dimensions of tha proposed in the repudiated agreement will "be eventually necessary. Whence can it come in the present circumstances? If from an outside source then the experience of the China Realty will hardly encourage the idea that the source will b readily available. The Chin Realty were fortunate in that the Government's abrupt intervention prevented them from losing little more than brokerage in prospect. On some future occasion the intervention might occur later with more serious financial results. If the Government decide to finance the new organisation will it be justified in such an adventure at a time when funds are so low that even s own officials are drawing only a portion of their meagre salaries and that other pressing Jobligations are unfulfilled? 7 makes the impulsive action taken all the more regrettable. On the announcement of the agreement to which it took such grave—and perhaps not alto-frother unjustified—exception, the Government could easily have put itself in good standing bby entering its formal objections. Then, in negotiation with the parties to that agreement—or by. Teyal if necessary—it could obtain such modifications the belief that the Vice-Minister of Communications,—whose resignation, incidentally, has now been accepted, had' failed in his duty should not have blinded it to the importance of proceeding by rule of law. In "rugger" parlance the Government seems, in its possibly well-founded annoyance, to have left the ball and gone for the man, The excitement of the moment rendered -it impervious to considerations. by which, to do it justice, it has been scrupulously bound of late. The position is not beyond remedy. Fortunately Mr. Soong has provided himself with the means of obtaining sound advice from the new directorate appointed by him. Some of the members of that body are men who know the importance of sustaining the confidence of commercial opinion. They are able to weigh up the defects in the agreement but they also must be equally competent to assess the damage likely to be done to the Government's reputation by action which spreads the belief that business transactions with representatives of the Government are liable to such extraordinary risks that they pass beyond the bounds of highly speculative enterprise to the realms of fantasy. It may be that" the agreement was negotiated by. one side, with insufficient attention tothe question of authorisation, although in view of the interests involved and the magnitude of the sum at stake, such a lapse would be truly astonishing. It ix manifestly disquieting that the Government should avoid legal means to establish or disprove its objections, and should calmly invoke the most arbi procedure without considering it necessary to give but the barest and baldest reasons. 'The business men now handling the affairs of the China Merchants' Company will know how such disquiet may react on China's political and economic fortunes.—Perhaps they will render their earliest service to their new charge by imparting that kno ledge to the Finance Minister,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account