The dimensions of the tragedy resulting from the sinking of the Spanish Nationalist cruiser Baleares is surely sufficient answer to the question, asked by a Labour member of, the House of Commons, as to whether it "was necessary that British lives should be risked in the work of transshipping rescued seamen back to belligerent warships. Six hundred seamen lost their lives while the British navy was able to save about 200. More would have been rescued if they had only heeded the signals of the British destroyers to the members of the crew of the ill-fated vessel instructing the men to jump overboard. For some reason they neglected to do so, and it is but natural to suppose that most of the killed went down with, or were sucked down by the sinking ship. Nevertheless some 200, who managed to get free of the doomed vessel, were saved by means of life belts and boats. The crews of the Kempenfelt and Boreas were acting up to the finest traditions of the British Navy, and there would have been much criticism if they had adopted any such line of conduct as that suggested by the questioner. It would have been the height of callousness if these unfortunate men had been left to their fate without any endeavour being made to assist them. The fact that they were members of a fighting force engaged in action should mean nothing to neutral sailors, and from that point of view there is no material difference between the Yolande receiving assistance from the British navy off the coast of Shantung and these men hurled to their death receiving aid in the waters of the Mediterranean. It is one of Britain's proud boasts that her naval men, splendid fighters as they are in times of war, are animated by the merciful desire to help people in distress; to have left these men to get out of their trouble as best they might would have reflected grievously upon British traditions. Able Seaman George Long, killed while the Kempenfelt and Boreas were picking up Spanish survivors, died just as gloriously in naval tradition as if he had actually been fighting for his country, and the fact that hells deemed to have died in action fully recognizes this.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.