The Archive · 1933

A Vital Topic

nin Tyurm ax Eaor of Comsuwisit an, the" New' Postament 'H. G, Wood, MAy Testers: Sens "Oak Colleges, Birmingham; Wis cee, cleat Cheatin Nowe:

Communiia AND THE AuTenNaTtve:—By Soveinent Presi London. 478.

urd. Penty, Student Christian It has hitherto been true to say average undergraduate was indifferent to questions of Fai ete dood with te wendemiz Kdenis were doffed with the academic Satter" world. In days when ean-when entering the "bread and

didates for Colonial services are cut by half: when, for the past two years, an unabsorbed surplus of, 7,500 tenchers has accumulated, yet is proposed to reduce the teaching stars in England by 8,000; when even for a junior post in engineer tug you can et 600 applicants, and conditions in every other profession yield similar figures, such things Ghange. There is without doubt. extraordinary growth of interest in Communism in the universities, both in its pure form, and as Socialism, which is more a question of practical Politics in England at the present time.

In. order to an opposition which has not hitherto been very intelligently in evidence amongst students, these timely volumes appear. They have been written, say the publishers, because "Commu presenting & challenge not only to our social oner but also to our religious faith. Whatever their final verdict may be, Christians ought to be facing that chal-Tenge much more seriously than they arent present doing." So that, ale though written for distribution these Thave a far wider ap: through the channels of the S.C.M.,

peal, and Mr, Penty's is indeed a particularly valuable contribution to literature on this subject.

Marx viewed history as a dialectic movement from primitive com with class conflicts and growth of muni, through private property technology, to end in a social order which should combine primitive psychology with the materialist gains of the individualist epoch. Mr. Wood rightly indicates that' only the second stage has any basis. torical knowledge, He then makes leal he Dialectic, the ination of Histor-

Importance of Tools, Economic Determinism, and concludes:

The, alleged. economic, detorminis

the atraitsjackot.of dialectical pro-story cannot. be restrained within gufetins and the nek content Unfortunatel Mr, Wood does not sez much to do ind by the downtrodden eased, and..pray for the never to disown the poor") can make of this sorry state of things, "if only we trust one another and work together for the common weal." As an academic treatise this book is excellent, as a means of weaning the wicked student from Communism it would seem to be in. effectual. Ax Mr. Wood himself Those who know anything of conditions "in Russia will realise that Mr. Penty's initial approach to Ca munism as a religion is a funda: mental to a true understanding of its influence, Deeling with the sian contention that material pr duction is the foundation and determinent of all_our other systems, religious, philosophical, or scienti says: was given by Mr. Christopher Daveson The neatest answer to this. theo when he, suid that the' spiritual Tependéne "on the mnterah inthe Sopendent on his dinner; but that the mpistunt lite Is no more the exeafion"af martial cndiians that Only" out "modernists are ea. crazy far to sggont. that lite nnd culture Shouia accommodate themselves t0 the machine.

There is a graphic chapter on "Communism, in Practice," and the question of the "Class War" mirably dealt with. From the viewpoint of the many, young or old, who Took dubiously towards an uncertain future, the most valuable chapters are those on "Immediate Measure and "The Alternative to satinism," and they are the more im-Portant' to the student of future events because they mark out clearly process which has already begun, and of which the failure of the World Economic Conference was merely a sign, Mr. Penty's conelusion is that the problem before us is one of national self-sufficiency, a return to the land in order the England shall be as self-supporting as possible:

The popular "idea that ye could only produce 'a tithe of the food we cangue is not supported by ague

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account