The Archive · 1933

A Majestic Musing

April 14.

The proposal has again been raised to purchase the Majestic site for the erection theron of Shanghai's much-needed Civic Centre, Town Hall, Mayor's Parlour—or whatever fancy likes to call it. There is no ground for supposing that inspiration comes from interested parties. In any case, assuming the proposal has, in 1983, merits denied to it in 1981, the Council is fully able to safeguard its beneficent intentions against exploitation. The scheme can be reduced to figures which will enable the Ratey er_to know exactly what it will cost, him and what he is likely to from it. He will also be inclined to consider the effects of the present operations of retrench-|hi ment in holding up such important projects as road-widen-. ing, the provision of more open spaces in this under-parked Settlement and the like. Nor will he fail to take into account the danger of following the example of Mr. Crummles who, having bought a pump cheap in an auction, decided to have a play written with a pump in it! $0 as to justify the purchase. Lively letters have appeared in these colurins on the subject. They follow familiar lines. Every one is agreed that it would be very pleasant to have a Town Hail. Ratepayers must feel that it is a little ignominious to have to hold their annual Parliament in a place of entertainment. The House of Commons may be the best Club in London. It may sometimes stage farces beside which the most extravagant performances of Mr. Buster Heaton or Mr. Eddie Cantor are dull, drab banalities but it does not so far as to ask Mr.

Cochran to take it under his wing in the Palladium or whatever: theatre of the moment is availlable to Mr. Cochran's showmanip. Yet there is a. certain unreality about the revived pro-Posal. It seems to be out of Psychological focus at the moment. Serious doubts would be raised regarding the advisability of embarking on a specula~ tive adventure in a year which, apparently, is to be the last of the 14 per cent. assessment years. There is much to be said for the argument that wise spending rather than fierce tightening of the purse string should be the motto of statesman at a time when economic revival is wanted. But should not, the expenditure be Productive? That point is Insistently raised. It_ clearly influences President Franklin osevelt in the framing of his afforestation schemes, Mr. Sowerby, who has done so much to keep the flag of culture dying in Shanghai and eloquent-their duty to study the flora and ly reminds his fellow-citizens of fauna of Asia, comes, with brave disregard of the accusation of being a sentimentalist, to the support of Mr. A. J." Hughes, Both recognise, of course, that the Ratepayers have to decide the issue, if it be brought again on to an effective platform, Both gaze frankly without flinch: ing on the financial disabilities lof the moment. They evidently feel however that, in the words of the auction room, this is an opportunity which may not. re-our. "Who ever heard of a city (except Shanghai) with a popula tion running into millions not having an art gallery for the exhibition of modern or contemporary paintings?"—so Mr. Sowerby throws down the gag Then he tells the poignant story of the Canadian Senator who was compelled to eave Shanghai without havin formed ans "adequate idea" the place because Mr. Sowerby was in the sad position of being unable to show him Shangh ublic buildings, museums, libraries and art _gallories, Canadian Senators are certainly people whom Shanghai would like to oblige and whose good opinion is to be cherished. Stone walls do not.a prison make but they also do not make culture, "Nor does the emption of the Majestic site justify view that artistic and literary taste cannot find sustenance here. The exper'

Lyceum, Theatre itself since the majestic movement for civic glory. Its erection was inspired by a comminal effort to give Shanghai a non-commercial place of artistic resort. Whether it actually could give Mr. Sowerby his art gallery may be open to doubt without a report from experts. The fact remains that, for the greater part of its yearly service, the Lyceum Theatre is devoted to the same occupation as that of numerous temples of the screen in the Settlement and elsewhere, Shanghai, like Congress, dances but it seems to find plenty of scope for the habit. hai, like another Congress, casionally talks in the mass, It finds hospitable roof-trees shelter that amiable aberration.

This appears to discount the enthusiasm of Mr. Hughes and friends, Tt does not really aim at that target. The proposal for the purchase of the Majestic site is to be highly commended—if the Ratepayers are willing to bear the cost. 'The mere fact that it involves the removal of the Council's administration from a most conveniently central quarter to suburban inacces sibility is of small account be possible in the ecstasy for culture to' ignore the facts and figures marshalled so powerfully to-day by Mr. R. C. Turner. Hearts as pure may beat in Bubbling Well as in the murky air of Kiangse Road. The really important matter is to cheer up Ar. Sowerby. Did his Canadian Senator go away unable to form an adequate idea of Shanghai? Somehow doubts arise, Canada ig a place of shrewdness and: ability to cope with the problems of the wide, open spaces where Senators are Senators and dollars dollars, Shanghai may have seemed a little cramped in style to the distinguished visitor but he at least was able to obtain impressions without" "unduly

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account