The Archive · 1938

HUNGARY'S CLAIM

The breaking off of the negotiations between Czechoslovakia and Hungary over the Hungarian minority question in Slovakia and Ruthenia is another of those setbacks which are likely to occur before a complete settlement is arrived at of all the problems arising out of the dismemberment of Czechoslovakia. Reference of the matter to the four Munich Powers is the only manner in which the impasse can be disposed of peacefully and factorily, even though Poland is reported to look upon such a step with distaste. That, perhaps, is understandable in view of the policy which Poland has adopted towards Czechoslovakia since the commencement of: the crisis, one which is clearly designed to obtain everything she desires from Czechoslovakia even under the threat of arms. It is fortunate that the Hungarian government has adopted no such line, and the reference to the Four Great Powers for settlement of the dispute has about it all the good qualities of orderliness which make for the maintenance of peace. It is to be hoped that the decisions which will be reached by the Munich Powers will be animated by a real desire to do justice as much to Czechoslovakia as to Hungary. Even at this late hour this is desirable, for as it becomes more clearly known what Prague has been obliged to relinquish it is apparent that it has been victimised to a degree which was never originally anticipated in either Paris or London. Even if the contention is accepted that Czechoslovakia ought never to have been created, the fact remains that that was done, and that in the course of its reduction there is the likelihood of as many injustices being committed as in its original formation. It is for this reason that the cause of the present breakdown of negotiations needs to be enquired into with the greatest of care, for it is obviously very undesirable, once this process of removing causes for past friction has been commenced, that new ones should be created to bring trouble in the future.

One of the main points of difference between the representatives of the two governments arose as to the map which was to be used as a basis of settlement. The Hungarians desired that one compiled as far back as 1910 should be used, while Czechoslovakia contended for the use of one of a much later date. Between the time of the Hungarian map, and that of the Czechoslovaks considerable change in the areas involved has taken place. Areas which were once predominantly Hungarian are now so no longer, and if the fullest justice is to be done to the doctrine of self-determination, and the adequate protection of minorities, it seems to be imperatively necessary that due attention should be paid to the existing situation rather than to a state of affairs which has long ago disappeared. The Hungarian charge against Czechoslovakia of insincerity,—that word which plays such a prominent part in international politics today,—on the ground that Prague has still eighteen classes of the Czech Army under arms, is typical of the manner in which Hungary and Poland have approached this minorities question. Comparatively little was heard of the matter until it became apparent that Germany was going to succeed in procuring the Sudeten Germans for the Reich, when the agitation was fanned in both Poland and Hungary. Whatever degree of reality there might have been about the German case, those of the other two countries are by no: means comparable, and there is every reason to suppose that, if Czechoslovakia had not maintained herself in some posture of defence, force might have been used to secure her acquiescence, and even more taken from her than is now proposed. The difficulties of the problem are undoubtedly great, and Prague would have been very ill-advised if she had refrained from taking the obvious precautions against the application of force, which was always a dire possibility.

How complex the whole question is may be perceived in the bare details of the Czechoslovak plan, which has been rejected by the Hungarians. In order to return some 318,000 Hungarians to their fatherland it would be necessary to cede territory in which also live some 300,000 Hungarians remaining in Slovakia. If in those other districts the Hungarians are in the minority it would follow that an even larger number of Slovakians would also reside there,' so that it is no exaggeration to state that in order to return 600,000 Hungarians to their mother government, the Slovaks would be required to surrender as many, if not more of their own People. It might be possible to effect some adjustment by exchanging the Hungarians for Slovaks in a modified surrender of territory, but there is reason to believe that so far as the Hungarian public is concerned there' is just as much a desire for territorial aequis tion as there is for the righting of racial wrongs. That and the contention of the Hungarian Right that the same attitude should be adopted towards Czechoslovakia as that taken up by Germany, can only mean a desire to force Prague to agree to Hungarian demands under threat of warfare. That, fortunately, the Budapest Government does not contemplate and the appeal to Munich is ample proof of its desire to reach a settlement by amicable means. Obviously it would be a hideous thing, if after all the sacrifices the Czechoslovaks have been called upon to make, they should be plunged into a war to satisfy the territorial ambitions of a neighbouring state. Such a thing might very well reveal the whole agitation in a truer light, but it is unthinkable that even the Four Powers would permit such a development which might have the effect of completely undoing what has already been achieved. That they will find some means of reaching a compromise is most earnestly to be desired, for if any degree of stability is to be secured in that unhappy section of Europe it can only be upon some foundation which has in it the qualities of justice. If mistakes were made in the foundation of Czechoslovakia it is obviously unjust that she should be made to pay the whole price. That is what is likely to happen unless a solution in equity is found.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account