Sept. 19.
China's defeat in her attempt to secure re-election to the non-permanent seat she has held on the Council of the League of Nations is decidedly unfortunate, for, as was emphatically pointed out yesterday, it is of the greatest importance that a country possessing 400,000, 000 souls representing so large a proportion of the total population of the world, should, within the rulings of the League itself, con~ tinue to be represented on the Council, It is clear from the figures "showing how the voting went that the decision of the Assembly against re-eligibility represents a revolt on the part of the smaller members of the League, for the policy of the larger Powers undoubtedly favoured the continued retention of the seat though they, of course, can be, and appear to have been defeated in the As: sembly suffrages. How far it does in fact constitute a rebellion against the domination of the League by the larger Powers, how far it is merely the expression of a desire to perpetuate the system of rotation on which the nonpermanent seat scheme was originally based are considerations minor significance compared witn the resentment that will undoubtedly be felt in China, where observers, even before' the election p took place, were preparing to look upon defeat as a slight, which, of course, it is not. It may very well be that certain of the smaller nations have irked under the feelings that the Sino-Japanese problem has loomed so large in the affairs of the League that their own particular problems have not received all the attention they should have received, in which event the exciamotion of "a plague o' both your houses" may very well represent the irritation witch has brought about so unfortunate a result.
Not much credence Is to be placed in the story that the defeat was the result of the machinations of Japan. "It is impossible to beeve that Japan would refrain from the opportunity of dealing China such a blow, but it is dim-cult to conceive that Japan, having made 80 poor a showing before the League as she already nas, would endeavour to exercise an.influence which in existing circumstances can never be so great as once it was. Further such an interference involved the risk that it might not have been successful, 1 which event the Japanese would have Tost considerable "face."
Without attempting unduly to criticize recent Chinese utterances before the League, it should be remembered that some have not been quite so judicious as those with which China originally won her ease before the bar of public opinion, and while it would not be fair to'suggest that she in part damaged her own case for re-election, there is room for the suggestion' that the Chinese attitude was not conducive of the success which was desired. That may also be found in the remark of Mr.
Quo Tai-chi to the effect that the decision is the League's loss and not China's.. To be fair it must be admitted that the remark was probably the result of irritation caused by the unhappy event, but at the same time in the hands of China's enemies it may be twisted to show that it is a matter of little concern to China whether she re~ mains with the League now that she has obtained from it all that she can hope to do. 'That would indeed be a pity, for in the past there has arisen' no question China's loyalty to the ideals of the League, and if one were to arise now, the very favourable position she occupies in the eyes of the world might be' considerably diminished.
There should be no talk of resignation from the League, though there has been such during the past few days. Failure to regain the permanent seat does not in any way mean that China loses any Jchance to secure adequate representation of her case, when developments arise, before the Council jor the Assembly. She is still a member of the latter, and with regard to the former the constitution Jot the League provides that when-lever matters arise affecting a member not occupying a seat on the Council, its representative may attend Council meetings for the purpose of seeing that its case is lamply presented before it. All, in fact, that China loses with the seat is a vote on the Council, and the right to take part in other discussions which may in no way affect her interests. It has been suggested that the difficulty which has lanson might be overcome by injereasing the number of non-permanent seats and giving one to China. But there is"a very great Jobjection to any such proceeding, for it would create, a precedent in accordance with® which any country's resentment might be as-snaged by a similar course, with the result that in a very" short. lime the Council would be numertcally as strong as the Assembly, which would indeed be an anoma~ fous state of affairs. Tt should also lbe pointed out that the loss of face" which is feared can only be incurred if China takes any action likely to indicate resentment over the decision which has been reach-led. After all is said and done, China subscribed to the rules of the League when she became a member. She has availed herself Jot the services of that institution to the fullest possible extent, as, it must be admitted, was her righ land her most politic course at the moment is to bow to the inevitable with a good grace and prepare for' the time when a more extended recognition of her claims may again lvecome possible. Tt must be emphatically pointed out that China received more from the League foun say ati f to members review of League assistance Jniven to China will speedily show, Jand to leave the League because it could not obtain everything it desired, would indicate an ingratitude with which it, is dificult to believe China @ould care to be reproached.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.