The Archive · 1934

RICKSHAW PULLERS

And the Welfare Question To the Baltor of the "Now-Cuina Dany News" from negligible. That they will use this hold for the good of others than themselves is to be doubted! Yet one could rest in hope that the dubious aspects of this situation might be held check were he quite satisfied of the ultimate relation of all this to Sim—The various reports of its activities now being published show that the Rickshaw Control Board is doing faithful work and making progress against the entrenched ers, The Board is to be congratu lated on reducing the rental of rickshaws from fourteen to ten dimes a day with the promise of cutting off another two. dimes on the first of next year, Actually the puller does. not receive four dimes extra each working day as he must subscribe (awards the "Pullers' Mutual Aid Association" or "welfare" fund. consequence on the he works he never does full time!) he may earn between three and four more thin dies than heretofore. His scant pitfance—a munificent average of tenor twelve dollars a month when he is prosperous!—thus looks tte less like a skeleton. When all is said and done, however, the puller's gain is very little. Tt permits of no wordy boasting about the generosity of the Settlement in righting the wrongs of an inarticulate and ted group of humans. Yet what being done contributes to the immediate welfare of the pullers by enabling them to do a little more to mest their clamant physical need We wish their straining toll would net them somewhat more but perhaps these few thin dimes extra Is all the strain the Seltlement's sense of jus tice can stand at present. A few sips fat the sponge of economic justice Is better: than none at all. But let those of us who settle their fate remember that they are getting only sips!

It may appear ungracious to carry this feeling about the inadequacy of what is being done into a direct criti. cism of the way it is being done. 1 with to be neither ungracious nor Unfair. I understand that the Rick: shaw Control Board is up against in-forests that are indifferent to justice cither In large or small doses. Tam aware, too, that, the tendency of the Wickshaw Hongs' Association to force showdown as to who controls the lekshaw traffic makes it imperative that. public-spirited residents of the Settlement support the Board in every possible way. That many are prepared to do even while they agnize that. the Rickshaw Contr Board cannot always go as fast or as far as they and their supporters wish Furthermore T am personally desirous promoting such support.

All this causes me growing regret that the Rickshaw Control Board hi Introduced into the situation somothing not in. the original Rickshaw Committee's Report and something to which neither they nor others have itiven the careful scrutiny applied to the rekshaw problem in general and the exploitation of pullers in particular. -T refer, of course, to the "Pul-Tera' Mutual' Aid Association" which is, embodied the "welfare plans of the Rickshaw Control Board. It would have been better, in Judgment, had the Board con. centrated on securing for ricksha pullers a modicum of justice in me Suring them a little more of the money earned by their gruelling toil and then taken up the issue of welfare by itself. The result of combining the {Wo {a that those who support wholeheartedly. the plan to force a red tion of rickshaw rentals and stop the trae In rickshaw licences find themselves quite uncertain about the "welfare" plan as proposed. The Rickshaw Control Board is this weaken ing the public support it needs. That] isan error in tactics T'wish to draw attention to some aspects of this "welfare" scheme that causing disquiet. The funds therefor are to be secured by having the rickshaw owners collect from the pulllers and pay into a bank the sum of $1.50 per ricksha per month. That is quite a percentage of pitiably small tarnings! This compulsory, collection will, it is estimated, provide a sum fof $180,000 a year to be used for the pullers' "welfare." That sounds proising. Scrutiny, thereof, however, alsos considerable uncertainty abou! ft and forces one to put the term "welfare" as thus used In inverted commas. One could overlook the fact that this "welfare" Insurance is imposed were he sure it fs all a matter of welfare. Then, too, it may be necessary that the rickshaw owners, not so far marked by any burning zeal for the welfare of pullers, collect {his compulsory Insurance. That some of the money, however small the amount, may remain in\their hands is Qisconcerting. Add to this the fact that rickshaw owners have the de-elding voice in determining the censing of three-fourths of the pul-Jers—10,000 of them are to be independently lcensed—and it is evident' that the hold of the exploiters on those they have exploited is still far the real welfare of the pullers.

The Shanghai Municipal Councit and the Rickshaw Control Board have Several times shown a fluitery anxlety not to overlook consideration for rickshaw owners. I confess 10} being much more interested in consideration being shown to rickshaw pullers. 'The legitimate owners and) the racketeers in their offing need no help. 'The pullers do. Obviously we must be sure that the "welfare" scheme really means the rickshaw Dullers' welfare in every respect.

The fundamental diffeulty is that this "welfare" scheme is mixed up with securing revenue for the S.M.C. Not al the money collected for *welfare" is Intended for that purpose. Yel insuring this revenue is well forward in the minds of the Rickshaw Control Board. In the Report. the! SMC. was assured that a nominal: fee would mean small cost to the licensing of pullers. The 40,000 rickshaw pullers are expected to Dey annually one dollar for such licensing. That foo Is to be taken out of the "welfare" fund! Thus about one-{fourth of the "welfare" fund goes int> the. coffers of the SM.C. By stretch of imagination can that be welfare expenditure! Tt has been argued that such a way of] raising this revenue Is necessary because many of the rickshaw pullers fare too poor to pay this licence fee. But with much greater cogency the question may be asked, "Does not their poverty make such a tax inequitable? If they are too poor to pay it one way why make them pay Teanother?™ One would like to ask. furthermore, why the public who. through the negligence of their Council permitted. this terrible exploltation' to assume such damning proportions, should not through the use Municipal funds pay for the licen sing of rickshaw pullers as a sort of Atonement for their moral delinquency? Perhaps the above suggestion is too high a level. for the realistic minds of either the Council or the public. "Here's another query which loaded with realism! On what basi of equity is the rickshaw puller required to pay the same. personal Tieenee fee ax a motor-car driver when there is no comparison between either the earnings of one who makes 4 living by such driving or of owner drivers? It is true the Rickshaw. Committee's Report mentions "n small annual fee to be chored and once dubbed it-a "nominal fee." But this fee is neither "small" nor "nominal"

the eyes. of a rickshaw puller, though it undoubledly appears 0 the well-salaried people who have, determined its size. Equity demands; tither that the SACO. bear this licens Ing fee or that it be adjusted to the economic strength of the rickshaw pul-Ter and be really small.

Now this camouflaged revenue tax fs, It must be noted, a frst charge]

the "welfare" fund. "One expected Feal welfare to have that place. Bu: hel In the Municipal Gazette. June. 23, 1994, ft is made quite evident that this revenue tax is to be paid before anything Is done on welfare. It was feared that the slow progress inevit table in the leenging of pullers would prevent the "Pullers' Mutual Aid Astoclation" from functioning until early next year. Yet the revenue must be Insured. It was, therefore, Intended that from the date of reduced hire charges the pullers should pay one dime per rickshaw per day fand the proceeds thereof be applied to the payment of their licence fees. placing the "surplus to the general funds of the Association" (tales mine). "Welfare is thus made to wait fon revenue! It ought to be the other way round! The necessities of wel-Tare should, indeed, have inhibited this tax.

Now the fact that the rickshaw pullers cence fee is made a first charge on the "welfare" fund may have no connection with the fact that the cost of the scheme of rickshaw' control Is a first and inevitable charge fon the coffers of the Council. But itis interesting to note that the sum to be taken out of the "welfare" fund actually somewhat more than covers the cost of the new service set no) to control the rickshaw situation. If tured for? T ha print denying such 2 use but nothing! bullining any, other. In any event} part of the "welfare" fund is used for revenue! The real welfare aim would be clearer if such 2 connection could not be 0 easily inferred. In any event it appears that while the SMC. is anxious to do something to protect rickshaw pullers against the Tacketeers itis equally anxious, if no! more so, to protect itself financially.

Teonclude by saying that the Rickshaw Control Board has made 2 mis-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account