The Archive · 1934

Challenge Accepted

To the Editor of the "Norm-Cinwa Dany News"

May I accept the challenge of "Moral Autonomy" conveyed la his letter printed in your issue of today. He writes "Now Sir, if these ims are, as your critics avers, immoral' and salacious" how is. it that they are day after day seen by good and respectable people?" As to the quality of motion pictures, 1 may state here that T have been a fall-goer for the past twenty years and have yet to come across film that could be called "immoral" or "salacious."

I offer no criticism to this: 1 would merely give my personal experiences of yesterday. Being in the midst of writing what T hope will be a useful report with reference China's industrial development and feeling somewhat jaded in the great heat I decided to lake a couple of hours "refresher" at the Cathay Picture House—this being the nearest came away thoroughly Jaded and with an enervated mentality which even a night's rest has not completely restored. How play censors can ass such a play as "Affairs of a Gentleman" "for Buropean and American audiences I cannot imagine: still less" can 1 understand how Europeans and Americans in Shanghai can allow such a presenta-Won of American life to colour the Outlook of the., Chinese people—the audience was small and mostly composed of Chinese!

It is not my custom to deal with such matters as this—in. fact only once before have I done this when wrote direct to the management concerned: and not to the papers. On that occasion, that of which I complained is hardly St for publics tion but I enclose it for your consideration. On this occasion I bold enough to write to the Press especially as there appears in your columns this morning a criticism of the play in question which reflects nothing of what T feel about this atrocious production. It is obvious to me that the very natures of those involved in play production and play criticism have become so jaundiced that.they are quite oblivious of their mental state and astonished when anyone tells them the truth. That this Is not a matter of squeamishness fon my part is shown when I state that T shall take the frst opportunity which presents itself of seeing Mrs. Pearl Buck's "The Good Earth." I do not feel disposed to discuss this very distasteful subject at further Jength but in conclusion would simply state that "Affairs of a Gentleman" has lost the Shanghai Picture Houses some ten to twenty attendances within the next few, weeks: Tcannot run the further risk of having to apologize to my friends.

Aupnea F. BARKER,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account