position of Burma when rated was considered when the debate on India was continued in the House of Commons to-day.
Mr. R. A. Butler, Under-Secretary of State for India," pointed out that the same guiding' principles would be applied as with India, He described the constitution for Burma, as a form of responsible government subject to certain safeguards and reservations.
WIN. Government's general policy was later vigorously attacked by Sir Henry Page Croft,—Conservati member for Bournemouth, He con tended that a small proportion of the population in India constituting the politically minded classes were definitely hostile or frankly dissatis-fled with the Government's proposed reforms and he urged the Govern ment to drop them. He declared that the recent elections ¢howed that the electorate was definitely opposed to them.
Mr. Henry Graham White, Liberal member for the East division of Birkenhead, and Lord Eustace Perey, Conservative member for Hastings, made rejoinders warning against policy of drift. They argued that risks might be Involved in the Select Committee's proposals, but their abandonment would entail not risk but certain disaster—Reuter, from the oficial opposition that it was Inevitable that they should proceed by slages. The worst of all errors in providing for a future, constitution was to imagine that the rate of advance depended upon a Ume-table. Changes' depended on what happened and on the way cooperation between British and indian elements enabled the scheme [be advanced rapidly oF other-
Sir John pointed out that both the Statutory Commisston and the Joint Select Committee considered that the only really satisfactory con clusion of the Indian constitutional problem was a Federation which embraced all India, both siates and British India. Since the report 0 the Statutory Commission, a new prospect had arisen as a result number of declarations which bad brought the. possibility of an All-India federation' considerably nearer, 'The question to' be decided was Whether in the light of this new prospect: of Indian states coming ow within an All-India federation, was wise and politic to provide such "an opportunity in their new legislation under conditions which Would secure the Princes' adhesion or whether they should decline to fake suen a step as too big a risk. This was the issue on which the House must vote.
"Every single surviving member who served on the Statutory Commission four years ago," said S.r John, "is to-day of the opinion that, instead of standing stifle by the proposals contained in those two. volumes, we should at any rate advance as far as the Joint Select Committee has proposed."
He added that, if the Indian states did come in, they would help to establish a federation of Greater India upon the only possible basis.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.