The House of Lords can be relied, upon to produce an informative wealt experience among its debate on India because "of the members. Lord Lloy4—in the place of the Marquis of Salisbury, regret tably absent owing to. ill-nealth—was, no doubt, an effective exponent of the ultra-Conservative view. His {position must have been difficult owing to the weight of opinion coming from peers like the Marquis of Reading whose trenchant support of the Joint Committee's Report was informed by specially acute perception of the realities of the Indian problem. The spectacle of Lord Reading answering Lord Lloyd was piquant. The two served together in India, the one as Viceroy and the other as Governor of Bombay. Theis views clashed then; the lapse of time has not brought them, apparently, nearer into line. The debate seems to have attracted an exceptionally full "attendance and the - support given to the Government by Eat] Beatty and Viscount Allenby must have a considerable influence on. some Conservative waverers. It is, encouraging to note that acerbity has gone out of the speeches of some, of the Leading opponents of the Government's proposals. Anxiety on this account has long troubled those. who have viewed the problem lest with the partisan eye than with regard for the relations of the two countries. In this matter a valuable Yead hasbeen given by Sir Arthur Hirtzel. That distinguished former Permanent Under-Secretary of State for India has broken an impressive silence in his retirement to reinforce Sir Francis Younghusband's appear for "grace in the matter and the manner of discussion" Sir Arthur, whose knowledge of the Constitutional problem is almost unrivalled. invokes the memory of the Tate Earl fof Birkenhead and urges that, in the discussions of the forthcoming Bill.
Parliament should let India "find us no nigwardly bargainers." That Is the solrit to which all true friends both Jof Great Britain and India will whole-heartedly subscribe. Coming as the advice does from one who has spent this life above or apart from polities It is hishty Impressive.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.