The Archive · 1938

A Wrong Attitude

June 10.

If the Kwangtung provincial government persists in its reported refusal to establish a neutral zone outside the city of Canton, for the reasons reported by Reuter, in a cable printed in another column, it will lose much of the sympathy at present felt for the people of that city which has been 90 ruthlessly bombed during the past few days. Oficiat sources are quoted as saying that the creation of such a zone "would not prevent Japanese aeroplanes from machine-gunning or dropping bombs on refugees within the zone, as the Japanese forces failed to dis ably safe, it is the paramount duty of the Chinese authorities to do so. Failure to take such precautions involves the Chinese offi~ ials responsible in a certain degree of blooduiltiness, and to endeavour to excuse that failure by alleging that if such precautions were taken they would be useless anyhow, Beeavse of what the Japanese are wrongly alleged to have done elsewhere, will in no Wway reduce the stigma which such failure necessarily involves. Chinese propaganda has Been so clever in the past, and so successful that there appears to be a danger that those in. control of it will overreach themselves. That appears to be the case in this instance.

neglect obvious measures because of an assumed conviction that owing to an alleged inherent vice in the Japanese they would be no avail is merely ta evade a very imperative duty, If there is any method Whereby the Chinese authorities can minimize the death and suitoring which is being me Aicted upon the people of Canton the obliga tion is definitely upon them to adopt it. Half truths, untruths or even prevarication cannot justify any other course, and if there are any means whatever whereby a great degree of safely can be provided for non-combatants and around Canton it will be a lasting re~ proach upon the authorities in charge if steps bre not taken accordingly. The question of nent of a safety zone for Canton should be investigated. It was solved suecessfully in Shanghai and more or less suc~ cessfully in Nanking, and there is no reason, the same amount of goodwill, which Tt has to be admitted once and for all that the definition of what may or may not amount to a military objective has been suMeiently going about it in quite the correct manner, for, when hatred and resentment conquer dismay, the bitter end is the only objective criminate between safety and non-safety_ zones while conducting military operations in Nanking and Shanghai." It is a great prevailed in these areas, in the south, why Pinch of the present tragic suffering should not be mitigated. widely drawn that it is difficult to see where which to fight. pity that the word "propaganda" originally

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account