The Archive · 1935

By SAPAJOU "TIME, GENTLEMEN, PLEASE!

Mr. "John Willie" Barber has decided that 33 years the Far East is enough for any man, and that really it is time to 90 Home. He sails this week. that the rate was low, Mr. Franklin contradicted him, and stated that, at the time the deposit was made, the interest rate was high. It was' also shown by Mr. Franklin that the signatures of Mr. Milton D. Purdy, resident of the corporation, and Mr. 1H, F. Payne, treasurer, appeared, approving the document. This" Mr. Franklin stated was fo prevent the China Finance Company from further payments, owing to the fact that copies of an unsatisfied writ of execution had been served, apprising the corporation of a judgment rendered In the US, Court againt Mr. Grant Mark on Mr. Hudee's claim for professional fees in connection with plans for the Grand Theatre. Thi sum. of $50,000 wi pald, said Mr. Franklin, to settle a "three years contract running into more than "125,000, which Mr. Mark had with the Ching Finance Corporation."

"it is unfortunate that the China Finance Company has been brought into this case at all." argued Mr. Franklin, "It didn't want Mr. Mark the position of manager, and aid him $90,000 to get out. Tt is Unfortunate that the defendant could not secure an attachment at the tim but the China Finance Company can not be blamed for that. This sum $25,000 was simply "deposited, to secure us against action or suit. We don't care who gets it"

Mr. Arthur Peterson, US. Deputy Marshal, verified the service of copies writ' of execution on oticers of the China Finance Corporation, and Mr. Hudee was put in the box to Speak on the matter of an alleged conversation between himself and Me. A. Loonis, who is named as the person who deposited $25,000 with the China Finance Corporation.

'Mr. Franklin lodged vigorous objec-_ tons' to Mr, Allman's questions as-JSerting that they dealt with hearsay. His objection was upheld by Judge Milton J. Helmick, who asked why, Mr. Loonis was not in Court.

Mr. "Allman offered the explana. lion that Mr. Loonis was a Belgian citizen, and the' Belgian Consul had stated that he was without any legal right to subpoena a Belgian to appear any foreign Court without supplementary judgment. "Furthermore, the defence refused to fle written answers to our interrogatory, and we didn't know what their admissions ance had no money or properties belonging to Grant Mark.

The Judge asked whether Mr. Loonis had been apprised of the! lease, and Mr. Hudec again was placed in the box. His testimony, "apart from a declaration that he informed Mr. Loonis, again was barred as hearsay.

Mr. Allman argued that the China} Finance Corporation had assisted Mr. Mark in removing funds outside! the jurisdiction of the US, Court and was therefore liable for the amount of, the claim.

"Again 1 want to ask you why you {didn't apply to me to get Mr. Loonis into this Court," said Judge Helmick, and Mr. Allman answered that he!

Jcould not know whether or not the testimony was required.

"Mr. Allman seems confused as to] the issue raised by this procedure, began Mr, Franklin. "His argument, jcentreing around ability, was an-[swered last summer when this Court dismissed a suit on that ground. The only question raised is whether or not the China Finance Corporation owed money to Grant Mark or had his money in its possession on December 3, 1934. T respectfully" submit that the record does not show that we had any money belonging to] Mr. Grant Mark. If the plaintiff thinks the money we have belongs fo Mr. Grant Mark, why doesn't Mr. Allman go into the Belgic Court and part of a preconceived swindling scheme, to take advantage of various courts" declared Mr. All "Mr, Allman is treading on dangerous ground. Does Mr. Allman sug-fest that Mr. Purdy, Mr. Payne and the directors of the China Finance] Corporation would lend themselves to any such scheme as that?" asked Mr. Franklin, "Are you trying to get into libel action, now?" countered Mfr, Allman. "it we went to the Belgian Court and got Mr. Loonis, he would say he doesn't owe Grant Mark anything"

Again the Judge intervened with a request for argument on the evidence before the Court, and, after few moments, observed that counsel had given him less assistance than was expected, and adjourned the case, indicating that he would fle judgment. would be," countered Mr. Allman. stated Judge Helmick. requested that Mr. Loonis be brought for examination. On the face of it, it is unusual that he should be making. a deposit for someone else's Mr. Allman asked for an adjourn~ ment until Mr. Loonis could brought in for examination, the Court! meanwhile examining papers in the In second thought, I don't believe! I will send for Mr. Loonis," said the Judge. "I can't see that' it would make much difference what the witness, Mr. Loonis, might say regarding this money." Whether it was [put up for friendship or was his own, T think the matter should be doter-mined on this instant. The Court has jurisdiction over the garnishee and the funds in its possession. Where the money came from is immaterial. It is there. I should ike to hear counsel discuss the issue on the evidence we now have. I will

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account