The Archive · 1935

By SAPAJOU

justification for extending the scope those criticisms by deliberately depriving land values of one of their most important means of security. The essence of the land mortgage system, as exemplified in the document on which the Sung Sing Mill was auctioned, lies in its simplicity of operation. The procedure is prescribed under the title deed. The rights of the parties are fully defined. "Hence the mortgagor can readily find a mortgagee willing to advance the necessary money on terms which compare favourably with any elsewhere. If this simplicity is destroyed and uncertainty introduced into the procedure by its exposure to the dilatory influences of political interference or popular clamour, the sufferers will be, not the recusant banks, but the commercial community of Shanghal—and ultimately Shanghai itself.

Admitting all this, some still say that the Hongkong' and Shanghai Banking Corporation ought not to have exercised its rights at this particular juncture. It should have shown political or economic wisdom in focussing its own particular problem against the back-ground of the general financial crisis, There again the answer seems to be simple, The mortgagor had known since October last that the nonpayment of his loan (to say nothing of the taxes and insurance premia) was under serious consideration by the Bank. That loan had been cheaply secured. It would seem that, whatever were his difficulties, it would have been a matier of common economic prudence to take steps to ensure the payment of the interest on it. Even then when, in spite of four reminders, he had not moved effectively in the matter, he was further advised of the gravity of the position by notices in the public press. These notices first made their appearance in the middle of December and should have given food for thought to ccritles who now pretend that the Bank's action has come upon them a shock. To come down to last month, when the sale by auction was duly advertised for a week before the Mill actually came under the hammer, it seems absurd to protest that any element of surprise remained in the situ tion. Surely the responsibility for recognizing the possible effects of the Mil's closure on the industrial and economic conditions prevailing in Shanghai, rests in no small measure on the mortgagor and his friends who either took no steps to deal with the emergency or were wanting in effective proposals to meet the legitimate and forbearingly expressed requirements of the mort gagees. This cursory examination of the circumstances surrounding the sale of the Mill is given with every desire to be helpful to all parties concerned. If the discussions between the Government and the Bank bear fruit, perhaps a satis factory solution will be found. but at all costs It is necessary to refute the dangerous contentions on which efforts to frustrate the Bank's legal rights have been developed. This protest is inspired not'merely by a sense of the extreme unfairness of the attack on the Bank and its Manager, Mr. A. S. Henchman who has shown great consideration and patlence—valid and important though such a stand would be. Thefe is a wider significance to be stressed: it {s firmly founded on the conviction that exposure of a long-established system for affording Shanghai sound credit on a cheap and workable basis to the dubious merey of casual political or popular battle-cries, might sound the death-knell of confidence in the whole fabric of Shanghai's business life and presage the ultimate decline of the commercial prestige and Prosperity of this great City.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account