March 7.
In this cloud of depression it is poor consolation to point to the {fair skies which may await Shanghai in the not so very distant future, Yet, when extreme despondency is abroad it is Aitting to correct possibly desperate views by recording the conviction that Shanghai should emerge from this crisis stronger land more prosperous than ever. The centre of world politics is likely to shift to the Far East in the next few years. The relentless progress recovery in Europe and America despite the hindrances of ill-con~ ceived systems of alleged control—will automatically stimulate a [general economic improvement. Of that turn in the tide Shanghai is exceptionally favourable position to take full advantage. And without venturing to indulge the arid occupation of the prophet, it may not be rash to assert that given reasonable political wisdom and competent statesmanship the future should hold for Shanghai even greater promise of expansion and development than the by no means negligible past which" has abundantly. vindicated the enterprise and capacity of the citizens of this City. But that, perhaps, makes the present plight fof trade here all the more vexing. The downcast merchant is apt to resent an invitation to make a Pisgah of his woes in order to behold the Promised Land which he fears that his present disabilities will prevent him from enjoying. He is not disposed to be enthusiastic when what he knows to be the lifeblood of Shanghal—its trade—is, stagnant and, as he sees it, in danger of drying up altogether. Yet exposition of his troubles may not carry much solace, unless can lead to some really constructive plan for their remedy. Meanwhile the only sign of activity is in the [speculative elements of whom it tean at least be said that they temper their disturbance of the markets with a direct challenge to complete lifelessness. The problem lot Shanghai at the moment is, in fact, that of preserving the vigour of its trade on which all the rest of its activities, of whatever kind, ultimately depend. To that end all {interests should be marshalled and combined.
Diagnoses of the present dificulties have been freely given, They need hardly be recapitulated Jat length. Cheap money in the [past has induced Shanghai to put its dollars into the form of property which by the very nature of the prevailing conditions, has seemed most secure and remtmerative. far has this process been carried that responsible observers have long held that Shanghai might be [said to be on a "land" standard.
[Probably the hand has been overcalled. Land values have been in-lated by speculation and over confidence. Now the situation has been complicated by excessive building with which existing rentals are highly inconsistent. Although the fate of the Majestic site ought to have given a waming signal, it [would be dificult to argue that the land "values have been recklessly Yaised, for comparisons with other land booms do not altogether support that contention. "Yet the evidence seems to prove that the present downward tendency in rentals is likely to be accelerated and must eventually apply a much-needed corrective. But the main cause of the depression is undoubtedly the unkind whim of Fate in electing to make political convenience in the United States of America depend jupon an arbitrary treatment of the commodity which Shanghai has used for currency. This commodity turned into land is not now available to redress the balance of events. Thus although in the past /high silver rates have coincided with Shanghai's prosperity for the simple reason that it followed the course of commodity prices generally, now when silver is treated artificially apart from the value of other commodities, its rise in price is not only coincident with Shanghai's depression but actually centuates that depression in a marked degree. It is most unfortunate that the long established axiom of the economic interdependence of nations should thus be expounded to China's disadvantage /without any apparent means of correction, until, by experience the expositor "discovers that political strategy is humoured dearly at the /expense of material economic gains. That is the situation with which Shanghai has to contend, so far as the outside world is concerned. It inevitably follows that in facing her problems she has to rely mainly on her own powers of recovery, in association, of course, with the [general effort of the country on [Which her trade and prosperity are based.
Arguing therefore that Shanghai, like China, is staggering under the {combined effects of an unexpected blow struck from outside and of a coincident adverse balance of payments, and that for Shanghai the position is further complicated by the frozen condition of her sets, it is appropriate first of all to insist on the importance of concentration on remedial action rather than on the development of those recriminatory—faculties which adversity is so apt to whet. Merchants feel deeply the absence {in this crisis of facilities which, in the past, have been available for their assistance in emergency. This feeling may be justified but abandonment to its extreme expression does not help, for, whether the fault be discernible, the condition remains just the same, Nor is it advisable to invoke the modern craze for control. On this point it may be pertinent to quote the view fof an acute observer on the other side of the Pacific in regard to his own country's crisis. In a recent issue of the "Technology Review", Professor Floyd E. Armstrong has jeontended that the American depression actually came to an end in the Summer of 1932 and the country would be well on the way towards normal business conditions had not the hand of control" in= terfered:
Commands proceed from those thinking in terms of socialized control to others who move (if they move at all) only in response to an economic incentive—the pro-At incentive of private enterprise Capitalism (which our leaders tell lus they propose to maintain) works, if it works at all, only in response to the profit motive and under control of manager-owners urged by this profit motive.
So far Shanghai has not been faced by any attempt to refute this argument. But citation of it is useful to point the general line which may be appropriately followed in smoothing out the present awkward creases. What is needed, above all, is a complete sense of ce-operation between all interests concerned in the maintenance of Shanghai's trade. If the pooling of resources be important, so is the pooling of goodwill and' business capacity. This is not the doctrine of laissez-faire but a healthy principle of encouraging economic forces to find their natural means of expression. The exact significance of the ordeal which lies ahead cannot be determined but if it should imply a general deflation in the true sense of that much Jabused term, it might not be so formidable would otherwise accrue from ill-considered attempts to apply piecemeal remedies, That Shanghai is capable of weathering the storm is not open to doubt: anxiety lest the process should be unnecessarily prolonged would be best_met by asserting the community's traditional qualities of the evenly-balanced mind and unreserved confidence in the merits of real team-work.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.