The Archive · 1935

NEWS VALUES

March 6.

The unusual spectacle societe Editor of the writing a letter to diverted London lately.

The older Journal had published from a cor-Yespondent a protest against the younger's cavalier treatment of Parliamentary Reports. So, after tu quo que which, in an editorial footnote, "The Times" had no dif culty in blowing sky high, the "Daily Mail's" champion discovered savour of "impertinence" in the publication of the protest and crushingly added:

T have very little space to give to reports of the proceedings of]

He proceeded to explain that, in those circumstances, he took steps to devote as much of the available space to speeches which supported his paper's particular point of view. 'This "authoritative statement of the practice of the 'Daily Mail' was tersely noted by "The Times!

being satisfactory in considering the point at issue: "the accurate presentation of the news of an important Parliamentary debate", This passage-at-arms has evoked pertinent comment from Lord Elton who controls the fortunes of the "News Letter", that weighty week~ ly publication which expounds the views of the Prime Minister on the subjects of the day. Lord Elton observes that the "Daily Mail's" practice 1s typical of the present Practice of the popular press as a whole. So the admission is "an authoritative statement of the greatest social importance" and involves much wider issues than the existence of the present Government Is not the drying up, or pollution, of its sources of political inform tion a threat to the very. existence democracy—a threat agains! which the BBC. is an. important, though as yet only a partial. safeguard? Again is it either right or expedient that any individual, however personally capable or upright he may be, should be able by mere money-power to purchase control over a great ration's sources of information, a control which Is #0 far-reaching and can be so arbitrarily employed?

Lord Elton urges that this is a most vital question and demands consideration either on the lines of extending to parliamentary reporting the practice enforced in judicial reports or by developing the possibility of controlling-ownership on the same principles as are now aplied to "The Times" itself.

In_ emphasizing the _anti-democratic character of this modern practice, Lord Elton is stating truism for the logical conclusion of such a practice is to be found in countries which, in recent years, have frankly taken their stand against democracy and have therefore submitted to a completely one-sided control of the press. But, without embarking upon 0 extensive a subject of controversy, it may be useful to consider the simpler issue of the proper en-

"lightenment of the public on the course of debates in Parliament. In former days, before the popular press was able to rear its head on the mass of semi-educated readers brought into existence In the two decades following. the passing of the Elementary Education Act of 1870, the daily newspapers devoted reverent. attention 10 the proceedings in Parliament. Even now the Press" Association issues to. all papers admirable summaries of the chates and those summaries are frequently used by the better provincial journals. London newspapers, like "The Times and, in Silesser degree, the "Dally Telegraph" and. "Morning Post" sti Publish "adequate Parliamentary Summaries, They also. maint that valuable feature, the summary or "sketch" by their own gallery correspondents, The provincial newspapers of the more Important kind are similarly represented in the gallery. Iti, in fact, admitted by most competent judges that the Parliamentary despatches to certain Provincial journals are unequalled those appearing daily in. any London newspaper, except "The Times". Some of them are fully deserving of the same respect as habitually given to the journal Which the Associate Editor of the "Daily' Mail" has detected indulge {ing in impertinence. There can be little doubt that if the "Yorkshire:

Post" or the "Birmingham Post" oF the manchester Guardian" or the "Scotsman" gave its readers. what the "Dally " Mall", "the "Daily Herald" of the' "Dally Express" considers to. be adequate Pa Tamentary tidings,—it would soon be called to account by its indignant readers who are not inclined to have fobbed off upon them Inthe. Provinces the kind of frivolous fustian which is sufcient to help the Londoner to: break the monotony of sex-appeal "stone sporting intelligence or crime sen-

Impartiality in the presentation of Mews and in formulating views is the ideal which newspapers in theory are supposed to cherish. It is often hampered by physical difficulties. whether of time or space. Yet by a really free Press it should be pursued with sedulous jealousy. Lord Elton's contentions have considerable weight, but the real trouble is that the preservation of impartiality in a daily newspaper can only run on what might be termed "rough and ready" lines. The responsible journalist knows exactly how to define it, but his definition is always in danger of being questioned by the layman. And the layman, in the last resort, is the effective judge of the issue. Nevertheless it is obviously um-Portant that the proceedings in Parliament should be intelligently studied by the electors and a one-sided report which omits all the speeches in favour of a measure and prints only the speeches con-dernning it is not calculated to develop sober judgment among those who exercise the parliamentary franchise. In a sense this is no new feature of English political life. The party organs never displayed excessive impartiality and, although the "Daily Telegraph" would undoubtedly have given to Victorians full reports of Mr. Gladstone's speeches, it may be recalled that it undoubtedly gave dutifully greater attention to Lord Salisbury's important pronouncements. But, when all this is said and done, there is little doubt that the popular newspaper has flagrantly abandoned all pretence at im-Partiality—and not only in political matters. The arts of suppression, compression and expression have been employed to deflect public opinion on subjects of all kinds. Tu these and other abuses the whole system of a free press is in danger, by reason of the justifiable criticism which they invite. The desperate remedy of official control is to be deprecated, but in England Journalists have been compelled to admit that reform cannot be imposed from within in respect of certain recognized shortcomings. Thus they gave support to statutory interference with their liberty in reporting divorce cases. They might be disposed to welcome similar discipline over the reports of Parliamentary proceedings. The manner in which impartiality has {been preserved by the British Broadcasting Corporation might well be taken to suggest a happy mean between unrestricted

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account