The Archive · 1939

Volition or Compulsion

The stupendous efforts that Great Britain is making to perfect the civil defence of the United Kingdom has been amply detailed by Sir John Anderson, Lord Privy Seal and Minister for Civilian Defence, while the publication of the air estimates of almost double the figure provided for in 1938 is sufficient indication that the other branches of defence have not been overlooked. it is one of the very minor blessings of the warfare, which has been conducted in other parts of the world, that the peril from the air has been duly assessed at its real value, and that there has been accumulated a large amount of experience which has been availed of in making preparations against possible air attacks on Great Britain. It is obvious that, but for the bombings in Spain, and China, the world at large would have faced a new war with much theer as to how the menace of the aeroplane was to be met, but with little or no practical experience. Neither Spain nor China have supplied all the answers to the problems which the military use of the aeroplane has posed, but in both instances there have been afforded object lessons which no other nation could afford to ignore. The result is of considerable importance for the perfection of schemes for civilian defence has been accelerated in Great Britain to such an extent that the whole system will now be complete this year instead of in 1941 as was originally contemplated. That has been largely due to the certainty which experiences in Spain have supplied, for these have made it possible to study the whole subject in the light of the knowledge so gained, permitting of sounder, and swifter decisions than would otherwise be the case. One of the most interesting features of the British scheme is that despite the fact that it is based upon voluntary effort, the appeal for volunteers has been more than usually satisfactory. A million and a quarter recruits have been secured for civilian defence purposes, and there is nothing to suggest that the full sum of 1,500,000 will not be obtained within a very short while. Satisfactory increases in the recruiting for the rapidly growing British air arm is another satisfactory feature of the means whereby Britain is putting herself in the best possible posture of defence.

The psychological significance of all this cannot, be over-estimated. There always has been in Britain a dislike of compulsion in the matter of service to the nation. Con-prion was instituted during the Great r with the utmost reluctance. There is at present the same dislike of the system though it is worthy of note that in practically all parties there are large sections who recognize that it may become necessary, and are prepared to support such a step directly the facts of the situation warrant it. There can be little doubt that in the event of a serious threat of war, or the actual embarkation upon hostilities the passage of the necessary conscription legislation would be a matter of very little difficulty. The voluntary response to the Government's appeal for civilian defence is of importance as clearly demonstrating how completely alive large sections of the British people are to the dangers which may threaten them. and thei: readiness to engage in such studies as wil) render them efficient in the event of disaster of war ever coming about. The existence of substantial numbers of men and women, adequately trained to meet the emergencies of war, will be a most important factor in dealing with the situation which must arise in the event of hostile air-raids over Britain. Large masses of population adequately leavened with people thoroughly acquainted with the dangers of the situation. and the best means of meeting them, will undoubtedly better stand the shock of aerial bombardment than people bereft of that leadership which superior knowledge can undoubtedly give. By such means the people are better fitted to withstand the initial shock of enemy air-raids, and when once that initial shock has been passed, the history of the past few years has shown that even the ill-informed meet subsequent attacks with greater fortitude, and less panic.

Humanity has proved under severe trial that it can, and does rise superior to the terrors of the machine. The process will be even quicker under the leadership which is provided by the arrangements of the Civilian Defence Scheme which is thus in itself one of the best answers to the still widely held theory that it is possible to deal a swift knock-out blow. and end a war practically before it has started. Excellent as the results which have thus far been obtained are it does not solve the whole of the problems which must arise in the event of an outbreak of war. The point of view is being gradually accepted that in certain events it would again be necessary to despatch an expeditionary force to the Continent. That would probably be little if any greater than that which crossed the English Channel in 1914 at least as a commencement, and the con: clusion cannot be escaped that sooner or later, and most probably sooner, conscription would have again to be resorted to in order not only to maintain initial strength but tu add that reinforcement which became s" patently necessary as the Great War proceeded. Consequently satisfactory as the reponse for volunteers has undoubtedly been. a direct answer to those who profess to find the Briton degenerating.—it does not really answer the question as to whether it would not be wiser to institute schemes for compulsory service immediately, or at any rate some form of universal training along the lines originally proposed by Earl Roberts With the high mechanization of the armies today it is apparent that training will take longer than was the case almost a quarter "f a century ago, and in view of this it seem: desirable that the men of Great Britain should at least be acquainted with the ru ments of military science, before the outbreak of hostilities forces speedy and intensive training. There is also the very great possibility that the knowledge that Britain had resorted to compulsory service might play a very important part in international polities, for an army in being is much more eloquent than one which has yet to be formed Many of the old objections to conscription vanish in face of the fact that it is no longer armies that will go to war with each other, but whole peoples, and in that respect it matters very little whether the fighting is to be done at the front or behind the lines Using the Roads The report of the Commissioner of Public Works which is published elsewhere throws technical light upon the problem of road congestion which every user of Shanghai's streets has experienced in one way or another. It points out that, with the restrictions north of the Soochow Creek and the establishment of an industrial area in the west, Shanghai's roads south of the Creek have been called upon to bear a strain for which they were never intended. As a result they have suffered unusually from wear and tear. In addition the impossibility of getting stone from the municipal quarry, which was formerly extensively used in repairs, and the difficulty in obtaining certain essential materials for road surfacing, have proved serious handicaps to preserving thoroughfares in the state of efficiency which the public has the right to expect. While the roads south of the Creek have suffered from an unusual strain, those north of the Creek, which were designed traffic, have had com-little use. is due to the complications caused in t the numerous regulations imposed panese, which have caused cargo to be unloaded at the Bund in preference to the places which were specially built for it. The roads in the eastern and northern districts have been put into good condition again after the hammering they received during the hostilities, and they are simply awaiting time when the Japanese feel that they can relax their restrictions to be used to the full again, This time would seem to be overdue.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account