The Archive · 1935

Admiral Woo Explains

PRATAS ISLAND

To the Editor of the "Norru-Cunea Datuy News Sm—An article. from your Hongkong correspondent was pithished by you April 27, 1935, and its subject was the need of Light Pratas Island. It referred to} Several wrecks which have occurred there in recent years, and about which you say, Mariners in Hongkong are of the opinion, that these disasters would have been avoided if a Light had been In existence. on the Island. Also, it states. that the East Pratas Islands Sea Products 'Administration has requested the' Kuangtung Provincial Government and the Ministry of Navy to have 2 Light exhibited there, The Article also quotes the names East Pratas Island and East Pratas Archipelago—which gives _your readers the idea that Pratas refers to a large cluster of Islands, which rather shows that your correspon: dent "knows little about the place' of which he is writing.

I feel obliged to point out, that Pratas Inland is a tow ving istand about one square mile In area Stout M4' fect high above high tie level. It ig situated in the western opening of a large horse-shoe shaped coral reef, which extends about twelve miles eastward of the Island: this reet is called Pratas Reef and sunken Below sea level and the ocean swell breaks heavily over it Inside of this horse-shoe shaped reef, is-a-deep lagoon about 110 sq. miles in "area over which numerous plonnacles of coral are scattered, and which coral growth is in perpetual activity.

There is no fresh water on the islands and its only vegetation Is a Tow sea-scrub. Tt lies on the open. sea right in the track of the typhoons (hurricanes) which sweep across the China Sea from March to October.

Until a few years ago it was! uninhabited and it is only since the' Ministry of the Chinese Navy established a Meteorological and Wireless Station there, that it has been permanently inhabited.

It is a "No Man's Land", for' the discomforts of dwel' there make it such. It is wing swept for about there is most oppressive and weather statistics show that for 75 per cent. of year, the horizontal visibility is tess than five miles. A few hardy fisher~ Jmen of sea products, visit and dwell Jon the island, at certain seasons of the year.

The island does not lie in the track of any shipping routes. Cautious navigators always steer clear of the island on account of the dim culty of "sighting it" owing to its flat topography and the low visibility of the sea surrounding it, The s. City of Cambridge was driven "on othe Reef during typhoon and even 100 lights on the island would "not have saved her from the disaster she mel. HMS. Suffolk who so. gallantly rescued the crew from the "wreck" were tunable to. find the Pratas Island without the aid of @ sea-plane, owing bad visibility.

The question of maintaining a Light on the Island has fully and carefully studied for years Post by experts of the Chinest Admirablty in ce-operation wit expert Foreign Navigators of China Sea, If a safe light for navigation was exhibited there, it would require to be seen for about twenty miles in d weather and which would require tower about or 6 hundred. fect in height; such a high tower would be Imperilled frequently by the typhoons (hurricanes) and it is almost impracticable to build such a structure there.

The Admiralty has also studied Pratas Island from the view point of a landing for land and sea planes with a view of exhibiting Tight beacon there; such a beacon would be a high powered revolving Projector that would show Into the Jsky and above the area of low visibility "which Ik #0" prevalent around Pratas Island.

All_metal and concrete on the slond becomes quickly weathered by the sea atmosphere. All winds Jabove fore 2 carry sen foam over the Island which causes the alr to bbe heavily impregnated with salt: the tropical heat quickly evaporates the foam and leaves a thick deposit of sea salt ever everything the wind comes in contact with.

This condition of atmospheres presents another great dimMculty to the maintenance of a light on Pratas, as the power of a light would ' be greatly lessened by salt deposits on the glass-shields protecting the light.

"The Chinese Admiralty maintain Radio Station and Meteorological JObservatory on the island, primarily for W/T Weather Bulletins and Storm Signals. However, this Radio Station is greatly used by the large Jocean liners navigating the China [Sea, for procuring Radio Bearings by Ship's. Direction Finding Com passes. This service is greatly appredated by all who use it and only Fecently the Captain of one of the Hargest liners on the. Pacific Ocean complimented it, by saying it wax the most useful W/T Station in the China Seas.

There are so many dimcultios and dangers connected with the malntenance of an ordinary ight-house Jon Pratas. Island, " that Tight-house experts of the World have warned Jagainst. it, An neral Light-beacon (Projector) or a Wireless Direction Finding Station is thought to. be much safer and practicable, but even these are not considered as vitally important for the present Tt would appear that the "Marin. Jers ju Hongkong" to whom you. Fefer, must be those sitting at foe Jdesks, for our recent inquiries of [Ocean Liner Navigators of the China Sea has not supported the advis~ ability of a Light on Pratas Island.

T shall be much obliged if you permit this loller to appear in your correspondence columns so that the public may know a few true tacts ut Pratas Island and Rect.

Cua Const Guan ADstintsrnarion Roan-Apseimat. 1. N- Woo, Director. Shanghai, May 2.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account