The Archive · 1935

THE RESIGNATION

Dec, 20.

The dramatic resignation of Sir JSamuel Hoare from his office as [Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, on the eve of a momentous Jéebate in the House of Commons Jdoes not come as a very great surprise, because the' possibility of Jsuch a step being taken has been {freely canvassed for some days past. in Rome it has caused dismay and Joewilderment, and some wonder as whether it will not lead to the Jwhole of the peace proposals being thrown into the melting pot. In Berlin it arouses speculation is to whether Mr. Baldwin's government lurider the pressure of British public opinion will not revise its policy towards Italy. Geneva is amazed Jand stricken with regret, and in [Paris it it feared that this resignation will render M. Laval's position Jprecatious and possibly involve Jeither his resignation or his defeat jin the Chamber. And the Ethispian Jdclegation at Geneva frankly admits that it is delighted. It was only to} expected that so important a Jdevelopment would create a sensation not only because of the personal Jaspect, but also because of the dem-Jonstration of the solidity of British Public opinion behind the ideals of the League of Nations. As this Journal has already indicated the Hoare-Laval suggested basis for [Peace negotiations between Italy Jand Ethiopia were not consonant ]with the ideals represented by the Covenant of the League.. There was Ino method by which they could be made so. They represented an attempt to solve a dim cult problem along the lines of peace at any price, ]with Abyssinia doing all the paying.

It is more than likely that Mr, /Baldwin's statement in the House of Commons which will have been made by the time these lines appear in print, together with the personal statement that Sir Samuel Hoare is expected to make from the back benches, will do much to mollify public opinion, and extricate the Jgovernment from a very unhappy position, It is inconceivable that Sir JSamue! and the Government were }without very grave reasons for departing from set policy in the manner which the suggestions indicate they did, and it is possible that when those reasons are made plain, as it is said they will be. the grave disapproval of a large section of British opinion will be to a great Jextent ameliorated. For the moment, Ihowever, it is necessary to consider the apparent implications of this latest development, The most readily perceptible is of great importance to Italy. British public opinion Is so strongly in support of the League of Nations and all that, jit stands for, that a government Jwhich departed from what is after fall the popular policy stood in some [danger of defeat, so shortly after its victory at the General Election, in /which one of its main claims to support was its avowed adherence to [League principles. Rarely has that public opinion been so forcefully demonstrated, and it is to be taken mean that Britons in the majority cannot be made to approve of the campaign of spatiation which is being prosecuted in Ethiopia.

Tt is still within the bounds possibility that some concessions at {the expense of Abyssinia will have to be made to Italy. In a certain sense that fact can be excused, though, perhaps, not justified. But Hoare-Laval suggestions represent, imum thi British opinion is willing to concede, Jand that Italian hopes of securing Jmore with the willing consent of Britain should be extensively modified. Mr. Baldwin has made it plain that the French Government is standing shoulder to shoulder with Britain in this matter. The uncertainty of the French attitude with regard to the question of support for the British navy in the event of Italian aggression has been dispelled by Mr. Baldwin's latest statement, and there exists at pres-lent a degree of unity between Lon-Jdon and Paris which it may be anticipated, will still have a pro found effect in Geneva. At the Jsame time it should not be forgotten [that the position, grave as it 's, is fraught with graver possibilities. For the moment tension in Britain has been eased, but the storm clouds Ihave in no way disappeared, and the greatest demands will be made upon British statesmen if calm and confidence are to be completely restored. Nevertheless there is, Jalways some good to come out of Jevery evil, and in this case it is to bbe found in the very imperative mandate which opinion in Britain has again given the government. (Thers is every indication that it would be fatal to Mr. Baldwin's government if it ignored the def-finite instructions given it by the Jclectorate at the recent polls and emphasised so strikingly by these lates: developments.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account