The Archive · 1936

Reply to Mr. Weld

BRITAIN AND AMERICA

To the Editor of the "Nowm-Citsa Day News"

Sm—The misquotations' of Mr. Perenson-Weyp are as nothing in comparison with the misapprehensions under which he Is labouring as revealed in his recent contribution to your columns, It has been my good fortune to be associated with Americans both at home and in the States for the last forty years and there has always been the most Kindly feeling between usin no single case has this spirit of friendliness been interfered with, T therefore very strongly resent the deliberate attempt made by Mr. Weld to spoil this relationship.

Some little time ago I happened to be stranded in Bombay" Railway Station for half-an-hour and quite accidentally took up a book, written by an American, which "was an indictment of British polley in India, turned to the end and there found formulated three main charges against us. Two of those I was in some sense an authority on, One of these charges was that we had stolen the Indigo industry from the poor Indian farmer. Now the facts are that India stole the Indigo trade from Brita! there is not a Woad farm in Britain to-day. And Britain helped Indi in this stealing—if this Is the right word to use. 'Then It was the Germans who with their synthetic indigo stole the trade from India; and Britain did everything possible to frustrate this stealing, my old colleague—Professor A. G, Perkin, probably the greatest living' authorliy on natural dyestuffs—being engaged for yours in an attempt to maintain the economic culture of natural Indigo. charge T was equally fand knew that It was equally. fallalous. And the third by inference could not but regard as equally une trustworthy, Then T realized that there were Americans whose enmity ayainst Britain was such that they would not hesitate to build up a case against Ther, facts or no facts. Now Mr. Perensox-WeLD, intentionally or un: [intentionally, is in this position and little og his' representations may acceptable to those who really know and understand the facts, there may be those who, not knowing the facts may be unduly influenced: hence thr Tettor.

'Me, Weto is apparently quite ixnes ant of the fact that the, victories of the British armies over' the French, particularly in Canada, made possible the rebellion of the' New England Slater, The Uniled States have never repudiated their debt to Britain in freeing them from the menace of France but they have never paid it and never will be asked to do so the two countries now know that they' must stand shoulder to shoulder looking forwards and leave the past to Took after itself, 'Then Mr, Wet is evidently ignorant of the fact that to this day the French Canadians find very serious fault with Britain for not claiming what was really hers as the conqueror of Canada, Canada then extending down the' Mississippi as is amply shown by the place-names to this day. Thus Britain, s0 far from being grasping power, did not even claim her rights so much did she feet that the prleo to be pald was too high, And T may toll Me, Wet that as 0 fairly extensive traveller T am doubtful whether, looked at from the point of view of world-aggrandisoment, we have not paid far too high a price for certain of our Dominions. "But the matter may be quila otherwise from' the point of view of world services. Iam afraid that T dare not forge this on Mr, Weto, for to judge his Teller his policy is "to give a ido a bad name and hang him."

The truth Is, of course, that the roles of the Unlled States and Britain in world-service are complementary {o one anotier—the States has been and 1s a great land colonizing power and Britain a grent coa colonizing power, What the States did in feolonizing the West and Middle-West, Britain has done correspondingly in colonizing her ocean-knit Jands and it would be a erying shame were biased individuals allowed. to inter Tore with the relationships of the two countries which: are so bound together in world.servi Apne F, Banken, Shanghai Mar. 5.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account