Now let us see the _additionat charge under article 842. The Coun-sol for the prosecution is right. This article is very broad and same can be applied In a number of cases. should even say that this article can be applied to.a lot of eases, but eer tainly not for cases which are men-foned In the speech of the counsel for prosecullon, And by a very simple reason, and that is that in all eases in which this article should be applied, a criminal intent must be Shown by the prosecution, as the wording of the said article says who-fever acts for another person in the management or control of affairs with intent to profit himself or tke third Person or to prejudice the Interest fof such person, and thus any act con-{trary to his action, thereby passing. damage to such property or interest, My Jearned friend, counsel for pro-Jsccution, shows not a bit of evidence to prove that the defendant tad really a criminal intent. Is it not logical and absurd to pretend that the defendant himself or some. third. parly had or may have had a profit from the transactions mentioned by. Use counsel for prosecution, or is it not illogical and absurd to pretend that all these loans, ce, were made with the intent to prejudice the in-{eresis of the bank? It is not absurd to pretend that the defendant himself, who was an employee of the Bank, Jgranted loans to third parties him= self, as proceedings In the U.S. Court for China and a testimony of the liquidator clearly show that there was. fan Executive Council who directed all tke affairs of the Raven Companies?
My learned friend, counsel for pro-]sceution, mentioned loans, which were said granted by the defendant, omitted to produce a single proof for the fact that some were really granted the defendant, and if he would have had a look ai the minnies of the executive council, it would have been easy for him to state that almost all of the said inter-companies' leans and the Joans of the members of the Raven family were granted in spite Jot isis clear and vigorous opposition. This is a fact which clearly speaks for the defendant and 1 wonder why the Prosecution have omitted to bring to the knowledge of this Honour-fable Court.
"A Worse on a Chessboara'
"My learned friend is Jumping {rom one paragraphs to the other, like a horse on' the chess board. If one paragraph "does not sult him, he chooses another one. He does' not Jeare to find out whether tke parngraph or article of the law really covers the alleged criminal offence for which he is suing, The forgot even the not too important rule that te Chinese banking law can be only applied for such banks which are registered with the Nanking Government, and maybe he has some know-edge about the fact that tke American Oriental Banking Corp. was re-fistered with the Nanking Government, but to the best of my know-edge and recollection, It was not, but was registered with' the American Consulate-General, as an American Corporation, "Now let us turn to the charaeter-Istles of the witnesses of bot: sides. T agree entirely and in all. respects {o all that the counsel for prosecution aid in respect of the compradore.
jut it seems to mo that it is rathe: peculiar that the learned prosecutor did not {ake immediate action. against him in connection with the transactions which were confessed by the compradore himself. Was It not because the testimony which is a lie from the beginning up to tke end, was intended to be used against this have to say a few words about the {estimony of Walter F. Raven. which was branded by the prosecution as a lie, and 1 respectfully submit that the said Walter F. Raven lad no interest whatsoever to take the whole responsibility on himself in respect of the Epport transaction, nor had he had any interest to say that he did not consult is general manager in the Young. transaction. That fact that he has his accounts with the bank overdrawn does certainly not constitute sum cient ground, to brand tig testimony as a tie. iquidator's Testimony "Now let us sce the testimony of Me, Hough, whom the prosecution saw Jat to brand. also to. be. either a fool or a lar and to say_ that he. while defeating the objects for whic he was appointed, and in order not fo make a laughing stock of himself, tries to white-wash a crooked bank manager. Tt is for the sake of show-Ing that the testimony of this man.
of immense value to the defence that T respectfully submit that all the liquidator hag said should be accepted the court as facts and all Mr. Hough has said are beyond any doubt. Afler all, what did tke prosecution expect from the liquidator? Did he expect that "in spite of the fact that fne is convinced that this defendant fs innocent, he would come to the court and say the contrary? Did he expect that a responsible man, aa oficial of the U.S. Court, would not have the feeling of civil duty to come into this Hon. Court and to say black. fon white that this man is innocent Did the prosecution expect that, afler carefully examining the affairs of the A.O.B.C, and he found this defendant is not guilty of any misconduct, that Lo would come to this 'Hon. Court and say the contrary? Did my Learned friend forget that, the Tiquidator testified in this Hon. Court under oath, and he is under oat' while performing his duty as liguida-'
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.