The Archive · 1936

Second Special Court

Legal Battle for Silverware

Another case was heard in the Second Special District Court's Civil Division on Monday, Mar. 23, involve ing Mr. and Mrs. Zimmerman of No. 10 Route Pottier, French Concession: The action was brought by Mrs. Freda Zimmerman against Mr. Morris Zimmerman for the recovery 6f silverware which the plaintiff said was her own properly, but which the defendant contended he had a right to keep. The plaintiff was not in court, being represented by her lawyer, Dr. O. Fischer. Judgment in {he ease will be delivered on Bareh At the outset of the hearing, coun-vel for the plaintiff presented to the judge an insurance policy and a letter of Mr. Joseph's brother as evidence to show that the sllverwar this case belonged to the plaintiff. An ex-house-boy of Mr, and Mrs. Zimmerman, Zung Sen-hal, testified that on August 31, 1034, Mr. Zimmerman took away the silverware from the house, This was denied by Mr. Zimmerman who said he never took it away.

Alter' some argument, Dr. Fischer, addressing the judge, said "The plaintiff' in this case was married to &n Englishman named Mr. Joseph who later died and left house and property at No, 10 Route Pottier, Shanghai. Among the goods left w fun carpets, and silverware. Since 1032, Mrs. Joseph had taken out an insurance policy for the silverware. In 1033, the plaintiff married the defendant while in Japan and changed her name from Mrs, Joseph to Mrs. Zimmerman in the insurance policy. In 1934, she it to Japan for a summer vacation and she stored the property in the storage company in the name of Mrs. Zimmerman, The defendant tried to get further money from his wife and, when she refused to remit any further money, he used illegal means to get the money. First, he tried to obtain the title deed by means of false pretence and mortgage it."

Continuing, Dr. Fischer said he had the evidence of the former houseboy. When the plaintiff wanted the silverware, the defendant admitted he had pawned it for $600, Dr, Flacher said, In conclusion, Dr, Fischer asked for judgment in favour of his In reply, the defendant asked the judge not to believe the counsel for Plaintiff because, he said, his allega-ions were without foundation, The defendant asked for an examination of the will of Mr. Joseph which, he said, never mentioned the house or Property, After mentioning that he wanted oth his wife and the ex house-boy's wife os witnesses in the case, the defendant stated that most of the silverware was with his wife in Japan. His wife was surrounded by crooks who wanted to spoil his name, the defendant said.

Judgment was delivered on Satuday in favour of plain and defendant was ordered by the Judge ito return the silverware to the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account