Aprit 15, The action of the Japanese Consul-General in presenting a memorandum to the Chair man of the Shanghai Municipal Council asking for control of publications indulging in anti-Japanese sentiments serves to draw attention to the whole question of propaganda in Shanghai, arising out of the hostilities. It may be said immediately that the Japanese are within their rights in making protest against the use of the International Scttlcment as a base from which to disseminate anti-Japanese publicity, for those who do so very definitely infringe its neutrality. As. with {errorism, it is absolutely undesirable that the Settlement should be used in any way as a place from which anti-Japanese activities may be conducted with impunity. To a very large extent that has been recognized "by authorities other than the Municipal Council, as witness the decision of the British authorities to secure control over the Chinese language papers, under British protection, who were engaged in sniping' at the Japanese. As it was very cogently remarked at the time, to do such a thing under the protection of Great Britain, would be just us bad as hiding behind the wall of the British Consuilate-General, and throwing stones at passing Japanese." Chinese who enjoy the safety, and security of the Interna tional Settlement owe it asa duty to themselves, and to all their fellow residents to muke' quite sure at all times that its neutrality shall not be breached. More thi that, there is something contemptible about people who hide behind others while ing in practices of which the latter cannot possibly approve, for it indicates a complete absence of courage, and a degree of cowardice comparing very poorly indeed with the hundreds of thousands of their fellow countrymen, who are daily risking their lives on the various fronts, would be interesting to learn what ence there is that these anti-Japanese publications are inspired by Chung It is to be hoped that there is none, for, if there is it indicates a sense of irresponsibility utter! the common idea of 01 the point quite lear, it embered that when hostilities the neighbourhood of Shanghai, the Chinese authorities were very zealous 10 see that the International Settlement and the French Concession should maintain complete neutrality. That was, of course, then @ neutrality vis-d-vis of the Japanese.
It was of service to both sides, for they were able thus to protect one flank, which otherwise would not have been possible. Of this the Chinese took the fullest advantage. There would have been very clamant objection, and protest if the neutrality which it was' possible to maintain south of the Soochow Creek had been breached in favour of the Japanese. In their turn the Japanese, having now possession of the whole of the surrounding area, have every right to object if they find that Chinese are sing this haven of refuge for the purpose of continuing a form of hostility which cannot have the slightest justification. That is just as true of terrorism as of propaganda. Thus the duty is incumbent upon Chungking to see that the neutrality which they so keenly insisted upon in the early days of the hostilities shall be maintained even now. It would be a betrayal of good faith, if, having received whatever advantages there were in that carlier neutrality, Chungking should now cease to recognize the common onus which it imposed upon the authorities of the International Settlement as well themselves. There is also the question to be considered as to what the Council can do in the circumstances. That their powers would normally be limited in the matter is clear, but unprecedented problems very often require unprecedented solutions, and if the Council find that in correcting the abuses complained of they have to act ultra vires, that should not restrain them from taking whatever action may be deemed to be neces sary.
That, however, does not solve the whole question of propaganda. In recent weeks, anti-British sentiment has been sedulously fostered by the Nanking Government, and has also appeared in the local Japanese Press. It may be trite to remark that in this connection what is sauce for the Japanese goose should serve also for the British gander, but the truth of it cannot be for one moment denied. It is not suggested for one moment that the Council should predicate whatever action it contemplates upon similar action by the Nanking and Japanese authorities for the suppression of this form of activity against the British, but it seriously urged that what the Japanese insist the Council should do, they should also do in this respect. The contention of the Japanese Embassy spokesman that Chinese newspapers in Nanking, and Hangchow were censored by the "Reformed Government" carries no conviction whatever in view of the fact that that government is a creation of the Japanese authorities whose word is law to it. It is not possible to establish different identities for the "Reformed Government," and the Japanese authorities any mote than it was to differentiate between the Soviet Government and the Third Interna~ tlonale. There can consequently be no ques~ tion as to where responsibility for the anti British propaganda which is being spread has to lie, Much has been said in the past of the need for ce-operation between the Japanese and nationals of neutral Powers. Here is a splendid opportunity of securing that ce-operation by similar action by the Japanese to that which they are requiring of the Municipal Council. True the two are not interdependent, but the fact does remain that if the Japanese have cause to complain of anti-Japanese publication within the Settlement, the British have just as much right to expect that their complaints in a similar con-ection should receive sympathetic Japanese attention,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.