"To the Editor of the "Nonrit-Cuiwa Darcy News"
Sin-—An article dealing with the proposed merger of the New Engineering Works with the Shanghhal Dock Company, apparently taken from "Finance and. Commerce." appears in your Issue of Nov. 28. As it entirely fails to prevent the position from the point of view of the preference shareholders it has bboen suggested by some of them that request the courtesy of your correspondence columns to assist us in correcting any impression which may be unfairly conveyed by the article In question that the preference shareholders were abusing their priuileged position to extort from the ordinary shareholders more than was fair as the price of their consent to scheme admittedly in the best, in-forests of all concerned. The situation is much more complex than would appear from a perusal of the article, "Tt would indeed appear probable that the ordinary shareholders have not fully comprehended the stubborn facts with which they are confronted, Before the proposed merger could bbe put into effect it was neces secure the consent of the prefer nee shareholders to the surrender of their legal rights inherent in shares this nature. The offer made on behalf of the ordinary, shareholders fag an inducement for "them to do so was embodied in the resolution submitted at the meeting of prefer~ ence shareholders held on Nov. 20. The resolution was defeated by 8 large: majority.
1's true, us" potated out in the article, that! the "preference shares were originally given to the ordinary shareholders as a bonus out of huge} profits realized by the Company. On the other hand it appears that they were quickly disposed of by those to} whom they were allotted and at this time only few of the principal holders of ordinary Shares "are holders. of Preference Shares. Tt was stated. al the meeting that only two of the directors, one of whom had acquired 'a small holding a few days previously eld any. Preference Shares.
"The distribution of the shares has an Important bearing on the matter. The Ordinary Shareholders with no) Preference Shares naturally look upon the latler as an incubus to be got rid. of as cheaply as possible, Those who have holdings about equal are, as individuals, disinterested as regards the: terms offered to the Preference Shareholders og what they lose on the: swings they make up on the roundabouts'. The Preference Shareholders must, therefore, exercise the greatest of: care in safeguarding their own Aegitimate interests.
The altitude of the Ordinary Share holders implied in the offer they make the. Preference Shareholders. analogous to a person who, having mortgaged his property, demands that they are not entitled to any shares! Jin the assets that have been pledged to meet them. This fact appears to have been entirely overlooked making the offer to the Preference Shareholders. As an inducement to them to accept they were offered a half share in certain surplus assets to which It was alleged they were not entitled. Apart from the very doub'- ful value of such essels the offer actually implied give up your priority claim on these assets and we will share them with you.
But this extraordinary offer goes to even further lengths in its sublime indifference to the legitimate claims Jot the Preference Shareholders. Tt limplied that the Ordinary and Preferlence Shares had equal intrinsic values which is far from being true. When Jan enterprise, with preferred shares Jor bonds and debentures with prilarity rights over its assets. is showing declining prosperity the market value jot its Ordinary Shares must decline Jmuch more rapidly thea the former which may even maintain their face value when the latter have become tically worthless. It is obvious, therefore, that the intrinsic value of the New Engineering Preference Shares now considerably exceeds that lot the Ordinary Shares. We have to thank the author of the article re-Herved to for having supplied incontrovertible evidence in support. this contention, He points out thal "since 1921, when the Preference [Shares were created, Ordinary Shareholders had received $1,554,545 and the "Preference " Shareholders $2,144,113." That is to. say the! latter' received during this period [98 per cent. more than the former. [Unies and until the company can Jearn more than sufficient to pay the per cent, obligation to the Prefer. Jence Shareholders the equity inves ment of the Ordinary Shareholders' Jin the assets of the Company frozen' and from the point of view lof interest returns their shares are worthless, The capital of the Compsny Jequally divided into Ordinary and Preference Shares each of the original nominal value of Tls. 5.00 The actual share liability of the latter is now increasing with the addition of accrued interest and at! Oct. 1 last was Tls. 8.70. This ability will continue to "increase ]with further accrued interest instalments as they fall due. Tt must be quite evident that the disparity in ithe intrinsic Values of the two Jclasses of shares is now rapidly increasing by the two factors of dim ishing net assets and the increasing lien on them of the Preference Shares. Thus, it would appear that juntes' prompt action is taken in coming to a reasonable settlement Jwith the Preference Shareholders it possible that to discharge their equity in the net assets will absorb very large proportion of them.
In these circumstances to make an offer based on an assumed parity of value of the two classes of shares can jonly be explained by over confidence jin the unintelligence of the holders lof Preference Shares or by hoping to dragon them into fearful acquiesjeence by the threat to carry on a losing game until all assets are dissipated.
But the main consideration which Hed to the emphatic rejection of the lotter to the Preference Shareholders has yet to be mentioned. This was very clearly stated at the meeting hough, strange to say. no reference to it appeared in the published report of that meeting. Bonds, debentures and preference shares are specially favoured by trustees and Jothers responsible for the investment Jof fiduciary funds, professional and retired individuals,' widows and theee relying on 2 very modest independ-fence." To. them security and an assured Axed interest return is of vital importance. They cannot afford to take speculative chances in the hope Jot realising larger dividends, The intention of the Preference share is 10 caler to this class of investor by eliminating as far as Possible the speculative element. Tk yields a fixed rate of ins {terest generally lower than ordinary shareholders anticipate realising and it confers no voting privileges, In return for these accepted imitations the preference share is Jaccorded the additional security of priority of claim over the assets of the enterprise. The preference shares lot the New Engineering Company are lot this nature and for this reason, is disclosed by the list of holders of, [these shares, they have to a very considerable extent passed into the hands of the class of investor roferred to. In brief these shares have been specially purchased for the protection afforded in the event of the very contingency that has now arisen. These shareholders believe, rightly or wrongly, that their intereats are sufficiently safeguarded and are not prepared to abrogate their
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.