The Archive · 1935

Author's Reply to Review

OUTER MONGOLIA

To the Editor of the "Nowru-Cuixa Dany News"

Sim—The review of my pamphlet, "The Truth About Outer Mongolia published in your Book Page in today's Issue, is so obviously plete' and based on assumption, ths calls for comment. In forming a comparison between the chapter en-Ulled "Historical Background," and the historical outline, comprising 56 ages, in Larsen's "Duke of Mongolia," your reviewer evidently misses the raison d'etre of my pub-Heation, which is simply to provide short, but authoritative, outline of Soviet ' Outer Mongolia. The condensed form of the Historical Background, however, does not detract, from its veracity, and the main events and dates are given. 1 would reler your reviewer to Benn's Six-Jpenny Library series, which manages to pack in a great deal of essential information in each of its volumes less than 100 pages.

Your reviewer also states that I "have -been merely concerned to give a superficial and not allogeth acceptable version of the truth on a basis apparently of Japanese information." If your reviewer did references Seventh Great "Hur:

Issued by the Mongolian People's Re-Bublican Government on December 24, 1904. Practically the whole of the contents is based on the inform: tion contained in the Report men-Yoned, and no part of the pamphlet {is based on Japanese information, as your reviewer so casually assumes. Furthermore, if my version of the truth, based' purely on Soviet Mongolian sources, is "superficial and not altogether acceptable," from whom fare we (0 obtain the truth?

'Regarding the reproduction of a photograph (page 22) from Marden' "Across "Asia's Snows and Deserts," there was no intentional "piracy." and acknowledgements ate hereby uly registered.

Shanghai, Dee. 3.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account