The Archive · 1935

German Wins Claim

The following judgment was delivered In Tientain on December 2 in the action H. Wellman v, Doney Ca, which was heard in LIN. Sux preme Court there by Judge P. Grant Jones on November 12 and 15 this action the plainti, " Ger~ man citizen resident in Shanghai, launs damages from the defendants for the wrongful conversion of two hundred "and" seventy shares common stock in the Socony Vacuum Corporation of New York which she had delivered to them for safe custody, and alternatively the sum of four thousand one hundred and seventeen dollars and Atty cents United States currency as money received by the dants to her use, The de times the agents Tienisin of the American-Oriental Corporation Fed. Inc. of 29 Nanking Road, delivery of the shai in question was made to and accepted by them not on their own account but agents for that Corporation, and that the ghates were not accepted for safe custody but In order that they should be forwarded to the Cor ration for transmission to Messrs.

'A, Pierce & Ca, stockbrokers of 40 "Wall "Street, New York, to be held by them pending further instruc-lens from the plaintiff; alternatively they plead that if the relationship of principal and agent did not exist between them and. the Corporation, they nevertheless purported to deal laintift to her knowledge of the Corporation. yas T find them on the admissions in the defence and on the notice to admit as well as on the oral and' documentary evidence ad. the hearing, are as On April 16° last the laintift, who had had previous ings In local shares through the defendant frm and was then think-Ing of leaving for Shanghai, took three certificates for one hundred, one hundred, and seventy shares respectively in the Socony Vacuum Corporation to the share department of the firm where she found present Mr. 'TH. Warmsley and Mr. Langebaek, sharebrokers to the frm, and a typist. She told Mr. Warmsley that she was about to leave Tientsin and did not know where she was going to settle and asked him to take the shares into safe custody for her. Warmsley asked Langebaek, who. deals with the American business of the rin, to attend to her. To the loiter the plaintiff "produced the three ce-tifeates and repeated her request that Doney & Ca. would take them into safe custody. 'The evidence conflicting as (0 what followed but it is clear that Langeback suggested the alternative course of forwarding the cerlifieates to E. A. Pierce Ca. defendants' agents in New York, who would keep them pending fur ther instructions from the owner; if that course were to be adopted the plaintiff would, he said, be required to indorse the certificates. which would then be available for disposal

ease New York through Doney & Ca. dividends could be collected through Doney & Ca, who would allow, her inter alia that the brokerage charges! for New York orders should be divided in certain proportions between the defendants, the Corporation and the latter's New York' represent tives, that defendants should provide certain margins on orders for their fients, that Interest should be debited oF credited to their account monthly and that the cost of cables between 'Tientsin and Shanghat should be for defendants' account. "Under this agreement the plainiif's certificates were posted to the Corporation at Shanghai in a letter of April 16 and were thence forwarded by the Cor-ration to Pierce & Ca, in a letter of 24 the Corporation suspended payment, and on or about May 27 the shares were sold Pierce & Ca. for the account of the Corporation for ]US.$4,11750. In their letter of April 16 the defendants had requested the Corporation to forward the certi feates to New York and "credit the hares to our holding with your-'a. result of "which the: ion in its turn requested E. A. Pierce & Ca. to "credit these shares our holding with you." It was admitted on notice that "on 15th April 1995 and from that date until 24th May 1935 the: account between the defendants and the American-Oriental Finance Corporation showed indebtedness in the name of the Jdefendants to the Corporation." The shares were thus treated, as Mr. Langebaek indeed admitted, as security for defendants' indebtedness to the Corporation and it appears to me to be beside the point that this indebtedness, may have been otherwise covered. lat of the defence is that the ints either were, or purported to be, mere agents of the Finance Corporation. Of the cases cited to me Gadd v. Houghton (1876, 1 Ex. Div. 357) decided that the words "as agents" and the words "on account of" were not mere words of deseription and the brokers who had. signed a sold-note were not lable upon a contract made for their foreign principals. In Universal Steam Navigation Ca. v. MeKelvie

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account