The Archive · 1936

Judgment in Macaroni Case Ao VEINERMAN B. O. Ve DASHAN Before Judge P. Grant Jones

Judgment was entered for the plaintiff in the sum of $1,29083 by Judge P.. Grant Jones in H. M, Supreme Court on Friday in the cast. arising out of a claim for $7.73748 Jdamages brought by Mr. A. Vienerman against Captain O. " Basham {for an alleged reach of contract. Alter being addressed by counsel, His Lordship also made an order for costs.

Mr. K. BE, Newman appeared for the plaintiff and Mr. M. B. Brown for the defendant.

Delivering judgment, His Lordship The plaintiff in this action claims damages for breach of an agreement dated June 4, 1935, whereby he was appointed sole agent for the sale and distribution of the products of tnt Teal Macaronl Factory, situated at ]¥i5-7 Avenue Pelain, of which the Jdcfendant is the sole proprietor. The falieged reach is the sale of those Jpecduets by the defendant himself, and the defence is threefold, that the agreement (1) had already been natively, (2) is oppressive and illegal or_ (8) is vold for uncertainty.

The agreement, as concluded between the plaintiff and H. D. Bonham, defendant's predecessor in the proprietorship of the factory, recited that the parties were desirous of working together for the distribution lof the products of the factory and provided that for a period of two years the plaintiff (1). should be the sole selling agent of the products in China and. (2) should tell no other [brand, while the factory was not to sell its products direct to any other than the plaintiff, The latter was to be responsible for (4) advertising and delivery expenses in Shanghai and foutporis, (5) general expenses oiler ports and. shipping expenses also, (3) was to pay cash on delivery at the rate of 14% cents per pound (clatises 3 and 11 were subsequently amended by agreement) and could fix the selling price at his discretion, "The factory (8) gua~ ranteed the quality of the products for six months after delivery and G3) "undertook to. store tree charge the macaroni purchased by the selling agent. Clauses 9 and 10 were as follows: "The factory agrees to supply the selling agent with macaroni products up to the working capacity of the factory, say 10,000 1b, Ber month" and "The gelling agent led to take delivery. of any aqwamtily at nny time but not exceed: {ing 10,000 1b. per month." By clause 14 the agreement was to be valid for the full period of two years, transfer 'oF reorganization of the factory notwithstanding.

Brother ay Salesman In pursuance of this eyreement the plainti" on June 5 "engaged his brother Alexander Velnerman salesman ata salary of $75. per mensem for the period of two years, and on the 6th and 20th of that month he took delivery and paid for 700 1b. and S00. Ib." of macaroni respectively which he had sold to customers." On June 28, he entered into an agreement with iwo Chinese Jcompradores whereby inter alia te contracted to pay them a monthly salary and commission and who com pradores guaranteed "to take delivery each month of a minimum quantity of 800 eases 20 1b, each case" for the period of one year. This guarantee was, however, modified by the next clause to the effect that, If the com= pradores were unable to take delivery the monthly minimum, "he plainti was empowered to sell the foods at his discretion, "crediting the compradores with the usual 3% commission." The compradores further undertook to deposit "for the account of the factory" $2,000 on the signature fof the agreement, "as advance payment for goods taken on monthly count terms", and agreed that "when, this $2,000 1s used up and stocks of the factory's products are suMicient to cover this amount, to pay in advance a further sun! to cover their letter of the same date by Bonham, who undertook 10 observe "any en. agements concerning the factory" therein. On July 1 the plaintiff took delivery of 11,765 Yb, for the account of these compradores, out of whose deposit of $2,000 he pald for them, Jand kept them stored at the factory' under trust receipt in accordance with clause 13 of the agreement. He said at the hearing that he could not sell much during the summer months when "macaroni spoils owing to the heat and damp and many, customers jate absent from Shanghai, and the same causes could presumably have been expected to affect sales by his, compradores; it has not been satisfactorily explained why on this. oceagion he took delivery of a quantity which was so largely in excess of his [purchases on June @ and 20 and was hot exhausted until the middle of October.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account