The Archive · 1938

SPANISH BOMBINGS

On-the face of the document it would not appear that the report of the British Commission fof Investigation into certain air-bombings in Spain has added much to the information already available on the subject. The Commission inquired into forty-six rail on Alicante, at the request of the Spanish Government. Of the full total the commission paid special attention to six of them and found that, of these, two were deliberate attacks on the civilian area of the city, one was an attack on the main railway Station, and one was either a deliberate attack on a civilian area, or a badly aimed attack on the port and marine station. A fifth, though probabi directed against the port area, was deflected by anti-aircraft fire, while the sixth seems to have been properly conducted. Alicante, the report declared, contained no munition factories, and practically no troops or war materials. The raid, of August 18, on Bai celona, the Commission found to be either a deliberate attack on a civilian area or a very badly aimed attack at the port area by an unskilled squadron, the raid on Sitges, of August 8, if the railway were aimed at could have been as effectively carried out elsewhere than where it was without endangering the civilian population, while that on Torrevieja on August 25, was a deliberate attack on defenceless civilians carried out in good weather and at a low altitude. By inference the 41 cases not covered in the cabled resume of the report may be accepted as having been properly carried out, and to have been launched against purely military objectives. It must be remembered that the findings of the Commission are, by reason of the way n which the inquiries were conducted, ea parte, for in the circumstances, the Nation alist not producing evidence on their side, the only testimony available was that presented by the Spanish Government. The report only deals with a very small fraction of the total number of air-raids carried out during the twenty-six months of the Spanish civil war, and is, therefore, entirely inconclusive on the major subject of the general bombing policy of the rebels.

The probability is that, if a full investigation could be conducted into all the air-raids, a much larger proportion of those directed purely against civilians would be discovered, but the fact that any at all have been found lo come under that heading, must be taken as proof that the policy of terrorism from the air for the purpose of demoralizing civilians has found acceptance in Spain, though perhaps not so widely as it was at first feared. Generally speaking the use of the air arm for tle purpose of breaking down the morale of non-combatant populations behind the fighting lines has found such acceptance during these past two years, in Spain as elsewhere, that it is evident that the time has come when the whole question should be the subject of international consultation. Military tendencies of today are such that it has been cynically remarked that the chief anxiety of the men fighting at the front will be regarding the safety of their relatives behind the lines, and, unless something is done to improve conditions, that cynicism will ultimately be found to be nothing but the simple truth. On the question of whether it is possible to arrive at some convention whereby this can be prevented there must be a wide variance of opinion. It is all very well to devise rules for the conduct of prize-fighting, but in a street brawl a man, faithfully adhering to such conventions, would find himself at a sad disadvantage. The analogy can be applied to nations in a bitter struggle for victory and perhaps national existence. The Great War, for example saw the introduction of methods of fighting contrary to all the ideas of propriety which had prevailed up to then, and one of the chief difficulties with which the nations have to contend is that with the establishment of conventions there are always the danger that some one or other will seek to secure the advantage which a sudden breach may carry with it.

At the present moment there are definitions of what may be bombed and what may not, but it has been pointed out, that the exceptions are so widely drawn, that it is difficult to ascertain where the rules apply and where they do not. Ports, towns through which railways pass, those in which munitions factories are situated—and munitions factories are to be taken to include those which tailor uniforms for soldiers just as much as those which supply him with weapons—cities through which, troops pass or may be passing, go to swell a list which seems to leave only isolated houses very far apart as the only improper targets for aerial bombing. An ideal of course would be to devise a convention forbidding the use of military aeroplanes against any part of an enemy country more than a certain number of miles behind the front. But then it is possible to think of a war in which there is no real front, one for example in which Britain may be engaged in a war in Europe without having landed troops on the Continent. The counsel of perfection would be completely to abandon the use of aeroplanes in war, but it is of such perfection, that imperfect humanity can be depended upon never to accept it. Consequently the outlook is depressing, or rather would be if it were not for one fact. It has been proved both in Spain and in China that the bombing of civilian populations for the admitted purpose of demoralizing resistance is not effective. It may create a very transient dismay, but, once that temporary emotion passes, it is replaced by a savage determination to carry on. That has been shown to be the case, for example in cities like Canton and Madrid, and the one real hope is that eventually it will be borne into the brains of the idolisers of the aeroplane as the supreme weapon of war, that in certain cases its high efficiency militates against the effects it is sought to obtain. It is ay poor thought that mankind is not completely able to legislate for the control of conduct during a war, but there is comfort in the knowledge that in the human make-up there are qualities which refuse to be daunted even by the most, terrible of inflictions.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account