The Archive · 1936

V. A. Test Action Won by New Deal

Washington, Feb, 17.

Contrary to general expectations, the United States "Supreme Court, by a vote of eight to one, to-day' ruled that the Tennessee Valley Authority was constitutional in so far it applied to the Wilson Dam project The Court, however, did not _ex-ress any opinion concerning the Norris Dam or the future programme of the TLV.A., and declined to ex-ress any "opinion concerning the validity of Government acquisition or operation of a local or. urban electricity distribution system.

The action testing the—constitutionality of the T.V.A. was brought by stockholders of "private utility concerns in Alabama, and the chief ground on which the Tennessee Valley Authority was challenged w the right of the Federal Government to compete with private utility rms Ju the sale of electricity, The ruling delivered by the Supreme Court declared, firstly, that the Government had the power to construct the Wilson Dam; secondly, that the energy produced from such a dam may be sold by the Govern: ment and thirdly, that transmission lines o a fair market for electricity developed were entirely. constitu:

The only dissenting opinion war that of Justice J.C, McReynolds, but Justices L. D. Brandeis, Cardozo, 0. J. Robert and LIF, Stone presented a concurring opinion to the effect that the case should be dismissed. It was their opinion that the plaintiffs had no standing in court However, as the ruling delivered by the Supreme Court concerns only the Wilson Dam, the future of the New Deal's electricity yard-stick Is ill clouded by "Toga questions

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account