The Archive · 1936

Before Judge P. Grant Jones

(Judgment for Defendants)

Mr. E. O. S. Christensen, who sued his former employers, Messrs. Frost, Bland & Ca, for wages alleged to be due, lest his ease in H. M. Supreme Court on "June 25 when Judge P. Grant Jones gave judgment in favour of the defendants with costs, Mr. H. A. Rocks represented—the defendants, and Mr. K. E. Newman the plainti.

In February the plaintiff was employed by the defendants on a month to month' basis at a salary' of $250, His work was to push the sales of Cow & Gate, Lid, for which the defendants were the sole agents. In the same month the agency was transferred to Messrs. H.C. Dixon Son. The latter firm approached the plaintiff and asked him to Join them. He asked to be" released by the "defendants but was informed that they required one calendar month's notice.

The defendants ico instructed the plaintiff that during the mont of March he should do inside office work and there would be no occasion for him to leave the ofice from 9 am. to noon and 2 pin. to 5 pam. On March 14 he was summarily dis: missed by the defendants.

His Lordship held that the defend-lants could dismiss the plainti' summarily because he, on his own admission, "did not obey their instruc-ons. Therefore he was not entitled to payment.

Trouble Over Sikh Store woan stet and others v, paxtanstNcit Vauoiry of snresstered, unincorporated Sompony of Indians Courses: Mur, Ranald MeDonald snd Ret Stone for Patni:

H&E Newman for Defendants Before Judge P. Grant Joner (Adjournment. Ordered)

The question of whether an ile legally constituted company could Sue an individual caused Judge P. 'Grant Jones so much hard thinking In Hat. Supreme Court on June 25 that it was found necessary" 10 ade Journ the case In. order' 10" consider this intseate point of Taw. The sult was brought by Indar Singh and thers against "Pakhar Singh, the managing director of the. indian Sikh Provision and Supply Ca, Int. Ranald MeDonald appeared on to hail of the plaintiffs, assisted by Mr. R.

Stuart, while the defendant was Fepresented by Mr. K. E. Newma 'Alter referring to the writ, azDonald, quoting' from the Hate ment of claim, said that the plalntif were the president, secretary and member et the working committee et" the company concerned. 'The Company was an unregistered, nine Sorporated. association of indians living in' Shanghai. They conducted ahop or slare, and. a. restaurant After quoting from the rules of the company, Mrs MeDonald said that the defendant was appointed managing Streeter on" April $0, 1983," and hat fecelved "approximately $9500. hed never furnished any proper ace fount to the working commilice of company's business, as was. te-aired bythe regulations, In spite at repeated demands.

On April 1, 1634, at a meeting of the" company's officials, "defendant aid that the would resign fromthe company, but took away the com= Dang's books, without having furnish-fanny. proper account. In. duly, 104 the working committee sppointfof nother Sikh' as managing. direc: for, and later the defendant, without the consent. of the. working" commit: fee, tetumed to. the premises of the company, end resumed control by The Judge: One man against company, Mr. MeDonald?-—Yes, ral like Hector in the Trojan, Wat.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account