The Archive · 1936

Counterclaim Put Forward

Defendant further alleged that had been appointed from time to time, who had audited the amount owing to him, and in May 10M it was agreed that the store owed defendant the sum of $910. $1749.38 was now owing to defendant Jon money advanced to the store. Plaintiffs hed also collected goods on credit from the Store, but defendant thad not been able to collect. the faniounts. Defendant alleged that considerable sums of money were spent by the working committee in the fitting out of the store, and defendant had rendered accounts of the yponey that lid passed through lo An alternative defence that the Jcompany was an illegal company, and should have been registered as limited Lability company, was also put forward, Further outlining the cise, Mr. MeDonald said that the defendant was the originator of the company, and he was the one who Was going batten on the money which he had "collected. After' the formation fof the company, defendant received certain sum of money in shares, and after the meeting In which the working committee of the company was selected, defendant did not put the money which he had collected Into the bank, which he was bound,

outset, he began to dlsregar by the rules, "Prom the, very the ules and regulations of the company.

The Judge: Do you admit that the company is an illegal association?

Mr. -MeDonald: I admit that it does not conform to the company acts.

'There was, continued Mr, Mice Donald, a great deal of trouble with regard' to the accounts, and as a result of the defendant's obstruction, from the outset up to the present day, During all the time that. a fendant was in charge, there was alleged to be a zogular and heavy monthly ess, of $300 to $400.- While defendant was absent from the store, there was a small. profit for the frst lime in the history of the star The Judge: Ate you suggesting that the mouse returned to the cheese?

Mr. MeDonald: [think the facts will show It.

"abortive Enquiries" referring to "abortive 14 "numerous other irre-Zularities" after the second oceupa-Htonly of the store by defendant, Nr. McDonald said if the law had no remedy for an act of this sort, It iwas a direct Inducement to people to recover by force what they had already handed over.

The Judge: Your allegations amount practically to embezzlement?

Mr. MeDonald: Weare nol ina position at the moment to Institute criminal proceedings, Titty may come later, The Judge: The question is when ther, being an illegal company, you th ordinary individual, You would not be in a worse position

are a not even Partnership.

Mr, Newman stated that his client had no objection to the administer: ton of the assets of the company by plaintiffs, or to the accounting, but hho was contesting the payment of the amounts. ascertal Judge would be entitled to make the orders against the provision store, but not against the "defendant individually. Defendant did not-read or write, and therefore could not keep the accounts himself. Other people had been, a pointed to keep the accounts, and unfortunately, the company had come insolvent. Because the di appointed shareholders had not got their "money back, they sought to apply the law relating to a company individual. The case was ad-

In the course of the ease, Mr, Me-Donald made reference to the "Law Journal, and mentioned a casein which Mr, W, A. G. Woods, a report er, had been round' to so9, counsel aflorwards in order to obtai a form the minute, The Judge: Apparently they were more conscientious and. took moi trouble than the reporters in Shang-hal, My. MeDonald observed that he had yet to see the judgment on the Fecent mortgage ease In which 0 df= Acult point of law had arisen. Ho had not yet seen any report. giving [details of the grounds on which the decision was founded,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account