The Archive · 1936

Australian Marketing Plans

Legislation to Control Trade Beyond State Boundaries Declared Unconstitutional Front Oun Own Comusronsenr Melbourne, July 30.

Australian plans to stabilize the marketing of primary products have been gravely disorganized by an adverse decision of the Privy' Council in what is generally referred to as the *James case." By virtue of that! decision, legislation by the Commonwealth Government and the various [State Governments to control trade extending Leyond State boundaries has been declared unconstitutional, and powers claimed by the Commonwealth have been seriously curtalled, Ino more than the control of marketing were Involved, the problem Jeould be solved without especial dlfjeulty, but the constitutional complications strike at the very founda-ions of State autonomy. South Aus tralia, Western Australia and Tasmania are jealous of the Commonwealth Government's encroachment} on State rights, and hesitate tos render further' powers to. the Com-Jmonwealth to "control marketing, through fear that It might establish, precedent for encroachment In other directions, 'The present development originated out of the adoption of State legis! than in 1925 to regulate the market {ng of various primary products. 'This regulation has' never applied to the: staple exports, wool and wheat, but has operated beneficially in respect of the lesser primary industries, [Similar regulation of wheat market-Ing has been considered by the Gov-Jernment, but nothing can be done until the exact significance of the "James case" has been determined by the Premiers' Conference next month, Not for "Dumping"

The regulations adopted in 1925 were in no sense designed to facilitate dumping in foreign markets. The objective was the stabilization of prices in the home market at levels that would ensure a reasonable turn to the producer. Australian production of primary products. greatly exceeds local consumption. The local marke being more profable to the producer than the export trade, was [consequently subject to periodic guts that caused instability of prices, and threatened to drive local prices down, to the same level as the return to the producer from the export, trade. To prevent this, the States, by legislation, set up authorities to fx quotas calculated {o meet the requirements of the home market. The residue of [production then had to be exported, usually at a lower return to the pr South Australian producer of dried fruits, Mz, James defied the regul ions, and exported his residue to /Syéney for sale In the New South Wales market. He claimed this justified by Section 92 of the Comonweaith, Constitution, which states be absolutely free. tion, are inclined to favour exten-Sion of the powers of the Common-Wealth, because their representatives dominate the Commonwealth Parline ment. For the same. reason, the smaller Slates are susplelous of en: stoachments, and without their eooperation a referendum is unlikely to result in any tampering" with the Constitution,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account