The Archive · 1937

CONFIDENTIAL REBATE

An Evil Practice

To the Editor of the "Nontit-Cunxa Datey News"

Siy=It Is often said that the practices of corruption in China are 430 deep-rooted almost as old as [Chinese history itself. Tam Inclined to question this statement, believe the common forms of corruption as we see them to-day are not strictly native born, but rather the result of contact with the in-Auences of the West.

One of the most prevailing ways lot corruption or squeeze is the s0- jealled confidential rebate, "In spite of all" the Government's decrees Jagainst corruption, this practice of Jeonfidential rebate is still going on almost everywhere.

Tre original buyer cannot always make his purchases in person, He usually delegates an agent to do the urehases for him. Teking advantage of his principal's ignorance, the agent, as the - practice. goes, will strike a bargain with the supplier. The supplier will Invoice the goods at so many per cent, above the tual prices. The bill will be pre sented to the original buyer for pas ment and, when that payment comes to hand, the agent will receive {rom the supplier his confidential rebate, 1 believe this practice came fir in vogue among the household ser-wants of rich foreign taipans. Cooks, boys and amahs will usually divide the spoils together. 'The taipans are (oe great persons to care for such trining "matters. And, speaking of social' justice, what docs It. really matter if "a halt is plucked {rom the bodies of nine oxen"?

But the example is soon imitated by society at large and the situation [becomes serious. The team of purchasing agent-supplier takes a" lot of beating. The dishonesty can never bbe detected if the team-mates are faithful to each other and. there is no reason why they should not main faithful.

And then how naturally and irfresistably the merry alliance. will Jeome about! Comes a purchasing agent into a supplier's amice, "Listen fo my instructions," he will whisper, "You make out the invoice at 10 per cent, increase. Reserve that 10 per cent. for me. Understand?" What can the supplier do but 10 obey these Instructions?

Or else the supplier will propose the purchasing agent in some such You give me the business, Ti know how to satisfy you. Say, what make the prices slightly higher Jand reserve 10 per cent. for you?" Many a purchasing agent wilt prob-Jably fall an easy vielim to such me The confidentist rebate, alas, has become an open sere. Even pulable firms are no strangers to ft, One is saddened when one thinks that even public offices and chant ble institutions sometimes continue fo allow their purchasing agents to enrich themselves at their expense, Working hand in hand with the sup: pliers.

Twill just mention one outstanding example of the social evil known as confidential rebate. I may incur the wrath of the parties concerned: bul it is my belief that the parties themselves, at least some of them, do hot view the present state of alfatrs with any real satisfaction, 1 refer to the confidential rebate' which 1s almost always given by the Chinese dispensaries to the foreign-styled Chinese physicians out of the payments received in filling these physician's prescriptions. "From the Point of view of the dispensaries, singe they can realize a larger per= centage of profit in: the prescription business, why should they be denied the right to let the relative physicians have a share of that profit?" From the point of view of the physicians, since the dispensaries take the Initiative in presenting them with seasonly gifts in the form of money, why should they not accept it and even fo ask for it in future?

The original idea of the dispenaries is 10 hope that the physician who receives their confidential rebate will "in future recommend them specially to his clients. But the practice has now become so general that a physician can count on his confidential rebate no matter where his prescriptions are filled!

T must say it is a real shame to the "modern-style dispensaries, for their brothers, the old-style Chinese drug firms, never bribe the physicians ju this way. And it is a real shame fo the modern-style physicians, for their brothers of the old schoo! never receive such bribery.

Shanghai, Jan, 20,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account