The Archive · 1937

MR. DE VALERA'S MOVE

May 26, Now that the full accounts of the constitution which Mr. de Valera proposes for the Irish Free State have come to hand, it is possible, comparing them with the amendments which Mr. F. MeDermott, Independent, has tabled in the Dail, to ascertain exactly how complete is the cleavage with Great Britain which Mr. de Valera intends bring about. The term is not specifically mentioned, but it is clear that he designs' to erect a Republic for the whole of Ireland, that its President shall be the head, and that it shall choose its form of government, dete relations with other' countries, and develop its life, political, economic! and cultural, in accordance with its own genius and traditions. The! national territory shall consist of the whole of Ireland, its islands and the territorial seas, pending the reintegration of the national territory, and without prejudice to the! right of Parliament and Government established by the Constitution, to exercise jurisdiction over the whole of that territory. The laws enacted by that Parliament shall have the ike area and extent of application as the laws of Saorstat Eireann and the like extraterritorial effect. The special position of the Roman Catholic Church is recognized with Fecognition of other religious denominations existing in Ireland at the date of the coming into opera tion of the Constitution, while the usual provisions are inserted pro-ling for the liberty of the subject, freedom of expression, with certain, safeguards, which do not on the face of them appear to be objectionable, while the only reference to the Free State's relations with Great Britain is fo be found in the follow-

For the purpose of the exerci of any executive function of the proposed new name for the: country) in, or in connection with its external relations the Government may to such extent and subject to such conditions, if any, as may. bbe determined by Taw, avail of, oF adopt any organ, instrument' or method of procedure used or adopted for the like purpose by the members of any group or League of nations with which Eire is, or becomes, associated for the purpose of international ce-operation matters of common concern, Mr, de Valera is in search of a modified divorce mensa et thoro: he desires a complete separation from Great Britain but would like to secure whatever benefits are to be derived from membership of the British Commonwealth or any other such organisation which the government of Eire might at some future date decide to adhere to. At present it seems he desires to be of the Commonwealth but not necessarily with it, though he might at any time change that view and decide to be with the Commonwealth but not of it, Herein is found the real reason for his refusal to permit the Free State to be represented at the Imperial Conference. To have done so would have implied an adherence which it might not ultimately suit his book fo observe, and however irrational Mr. de Valera may have been in the past, it is now abundantly clear that in his progress towards a complete severance with Great Britain he is pursuing a logically plotted path which should eventually lead to the attainment of his object. That the Irish Free State is not unanimously in support of his pro-ossals, is clear from the amendments to the proposed Constitution which have been tabled by Mr. MeDermott, There are about one hundred of them, based, as he claims, upon his countrymen's ties of tradition, blood and sentiment with Great Britain, Of them the chief follow:

(1) Recognition of King George as King of Trelan (2) Admission of the Free State as free and equal member of the British "Commonwealth, the president being defined asa Fepresentative of the King:

Replacement of the name Eire wherever it occurs by Ireland, Deletion of the paragraph recognizing the special position of the Roman Catholic Church and also that recognizing other re With regard to the last amendment Mr. MeDermott appears tobe Adopting the attitude that the State should not concern itself with regions, and that itis unnecessary to give the Roman Catholic Church a special position, "which, while it does not give it the rank of a State church, indicates a position somewhat approximating it.

It has to be remembered that be= fore the proposed Constitution is referred to the country at large, it has to be debated in the Dail, It {is because of that that the proposed amendments have been put forward. That all or any of them will be assed is more than doubtful. Ar.

Valera still controls the Dail, and should be able to defeat all the amendments which may be put forward in any way modifying the proposals which he has made. That is an Important point to remember, for it is clear that the country will be called upon to decide upon the adoption of a Constitution almost identical, if not completely so, with the instrument which has now been put forward, for the plebiscite can only decide upon the adoption rejection of the document, The probabilities are that the voters of the Free State will provide a majority for the Constitution, and that Mr, de Valera will again be returned to power, for while there have been mutterings of discontent with his regime at various times, it is clear that he holds the imagina-ion of the majority of the people, while the sop he gives to the Roman Catholic Church in the proposed Constitution may be regarded as Aesigned to secure the adherence of any" whom wavered in their allegiance to hi and the provision for the recos tion of the other denominations is skilfully designed to alleviate sears ud not scare off voters who might otherwise have been anxious over the special position in Free State altairs granted to the Roman Catholic Church.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account