Dec. 8, White there are features about the debate on the state of affairs in China, in the House' of Lords, initiated by Lord Elibank, which are completely satisfactory, eyes cannot remain closed to the fact that it was on the. whole inconclusive. That is perhaps inevit-bie at the present time, for if ever there was a problem which requires to be dealt with the greatest circumspection is that of securing the restoration of British trading rights in China. Fortunately, judging from the tenor of the report of the debate, clear that rose who were eric the "the British Ambassador has supplied to Whitehall, and it is now clear that the expose {of conditions which appeared in the "North {China Daily News" is corroborated by the information in the possession of the Govern iment. But yesterday reference was made in this column to conditions appertaining in Tsingtao, and it can be said without fear of contradiction that the conditions which are to bbe found in that port may be seen in other districts under Japanese domination. A eared fully, and well-designed onslaught is being made upon the trade of neutral foreign powers in China, and even those who at the moment are in receipt of discriminatory favours have no justification for believing that in the long run their lot will be any better than that of the nations which are at present being so attacked, Lord Strabolgi's speech was of interest as Indicating means of combatting what is now being done, but he asks rather a lot when hho suggests that even Germany might be persuaded to help in the task of appeasement by realizing the commonalty of its trading crests in China with those of the other nations who have already made their protest. Whatever may be the ultimate outcome, the purposes of the Rome-Berlin-Tokyo axis at {he present moment are best served by bringing about the state of dissatisfaction Which has at the present time to be noticed. Any step towards appeasement which envisaged weakening of the support given by Germany and aly to Japan at this juncture would not receive the endorsement at Berlin and Rome, and the fact will have to be faced that if Britain, France and the United States do by the application of that powerful pressure, which they have it in their power to apply, secure @ redressment fof their very patent wrongs in the Far East both Germany and Italy would automatically benefit from it. That is no reason why a very definite stand should not be taken Britain and the two other Powers in the Far East, At the moment it is apparent that the Dest results may be expected from the adoption of parallel action by the three Powers which have already manifested Tokyo their concern over the situation which has been created in China by the total the Government itself that something will Lr nerlladdr at tag ertansdber it ned jovernment were just as clearly convinced as} obligations, and the assurances which they have to be done, sooner of later, to remedy, state of affairs which does no credit t0 the Japanese themselves, and demands corrective action on the part of the British Government have given that they will be scrupulously respected. The process may be. slow, but the most superficial survey of the general situation shows that the three Powers conis well as the Governments of other nations whose rights are imperilled. The "North-'China Daily News" has shown consistently how foreign interests, including British, have been threatened by Japanese action in China. To general assurances that Japan is not. deliberately interfering with, nor discriminat~ jing against British and other neutral shipping, it has quoted chapter and verse, showing the ports in the Yangtze with which'the Japanese have been and are carrying on mercantile trade, giving the names of the ships and the nature of the cargo they have been carrying. Lord Elibank in his speech in the House of Lords has produced similar information covering a wider area, and it is not now possible for the Government to plead that it is not fully acquainted with conditions. Indeed. it has to be said for the British diplomatic and consular representatives in China that on the face of the debate they have kept Whitehall fully informed of what has been happening, and, if at this late date there does exist any misapprehension as to the actual slate of affairs in this country, it is by no means the fault of those entrusted with watching British interests here. The same may with equal justice be said'of the various representative bodies, such as the British Chamber of Commerce, the China Association, jand the British Ratepayers Association—nor must British correspondents be neglected in this respect.
Shorn of their thin veneer of inexactitudes. the replies of the Japanese Government to the American, British and French notes on the subject of the reopening of the Yangtze amount to point blank refusals. The general attitude of the Japanese authorities in China towards neutral interests permits of no' mistaken conclusions. The discrimination Which is being employed is a patent fact, and it is only natural that there should be a measure of indignation such as that demonstrated by the various speakers in the course of the debate. Lord Barnby's contribution to' the discussion is not satisfactory. It suggests. that even more will have to occur before:
Great Britain should be anxious, that it should ook at the whole situation from the angle' of common sense. He pleaded for patience—more patience!—and the necessity of doing nothing to produce a situation in which a settlement would be more difficult to effect, It is not suggested for one moment that precipitate action should be taken, but it is argued with all earnestness that the British [Government should now take into the fullest recognition that the time may be quickly approaching when something more than the registration of mere protests will have to be considered. Lord Plymouth's exposition of [the Government's attitude is satisfactory enough as far as it goes. The Government tokes the view which has been repeated on several occasions in these columns that a [steadily and increasing Japanese trade is being developed by Japanese vessels in the Yangtze. That view has been supported by evidence, which, according to Lord Plymouth, cerned have means at their disposal of bringing a pressure to bear upon Japan which could not in the long run be denied. Indeed [there is a great likelihood that the display of firmness, which a threat to employ some of the means available would entail, might in itself be productive of remedial effect. Their employment need mean nothing in the shape of war, though there might for a time be unpleasant repercussions, but it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that a definite hardening of the attitude of the three Powers concerned would have more effect than all the polite Note-writing which up to the present has been productive of precisely nothing.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.