Aug..2, Mr. Yotaro Sugimura, the new Japanese Ambassador at Paris, has told a French journalist that Japan's objective in North China is essentially economic. The statement is accurate, Its sincerity cannot be doubted. It accords with the general line which Japanese apologists are taking in the endeavour to explain away the present crisis. It} is argued that the anxiety of Japan to establish economic ce-operation {with North China, for the con solidation of the bloc composed of Manchoukuo, Korea and Japan, {s being accentuated by Chinese provocation. The recent adoption of the "new concept", the conciliatory speeches of Mr. Koki Hirota and, especially, his' immediate pre~ decesser, Mr. Naotake Sato, and the moderation of Japanese actions in China during the last twelve months or more are cited to convict China of iveness. It is alleged that, permitted to develop national unity and to journey far on the road to economic reconstruction, China has betrayed symptoms of over-confidence in her own ability' and so has been careless in handling relations with Japan. In articular it is alleged that "anti-Japanese" elements have been encouraged or, at least, not restrained, In other words Japan's moderation has been mistaken for weakness and, therefore, the operations in the North are reluctantly undertaken by Japan in self-defence. It is with no thought of territorial ambition that Japanese forces have bolstered up the East Hopel autonomous regime which has made contribution to economic ce-operation by acting as a clearing house for an extensive smuggling or "special _trade" organization designed to correct the asperities of the Chinese tariff Although—as is shown by General Kiyoshi Katsuki's prompt appointment of a successor to Mr, Yin Ju-keng as head of the East Hope administration at Tungchow and by the creation of Peace Maintenance Commissions to govern the Peiping and Tientsin areas—Japanese control in Hopel is now a fait accompli, the contention is that the arrangement gives a beneficent framework Sino-Japanese economic cooperation for the better government of North China, This sort of argument wontd be more impressive if it were not vitiated by the actual facts of Japanese activities in North China and beyond since Sept, 1931, The short-lived "peace and order committees" created to give regional self-government just after the Mulkden incident were commended in precisely the same terms as are now being applied to the "Peace Maintenance Commissions". It will be recalled that they failed because the compliance of the Chinese nominees invariably broke down before the provocative rigour of Japanese masterfulness. Judging from the names of the men chosen for the honour of accepting Japanese orders in Peiping, Tientsin and Tungchow, there is no reason to believe that North China will avoid the vicissitudes of Manchuria, In other words the Japanese Government's no doubt genuine desire to avoid territorial commitments—a desire strongly expressed in 1931—will be defeated by the logical consequence of Japanese military action on the spot. It is to be feared, therefore, that the effort to refute the general impression that, whoever fired the first shot at Marco Polo Bridge, the Japanese military have assumed the role of aggressor cannot be successfully attempted by academic concentration on Tokyo's oratory. Coneiliatory speeches have thole merit, but they avail Uttle if they be not reinforced by action. It is more pertinent perhaps to note that General Kiyoshi Katsuki has disdained to echo the moderation of his superiors at Tokyo and, coming to "chastise the outrageous Chinese", he has matched his actions with his words, with inconvenient} bluntness. Blindness in Tokyo to the fact that commendation of the "new, concept" in Sino-Japanese relations hasbeen consistently undermined by the astounding tactlessness and, frequently, arrogance of Japanese military' forces in various; parts of China has led to a complete misconception of the present} crisis by Japanese who, in no sense, can be accused of any other desire than to deal with China in a spirit of friendly equality. 'That is the tragedy of the situation, It has been accentuated by' ill-conceived propaganda by which the most trivial incident has been magnified for home consumption in Japan for the purpose of. maintaining the theory that "anti-Japanese" sentiments and activities are chief attributes of Chinese occasions.
The main difference between the Chinese and Japanese Governments has, in the meantime, been ignored. Both are ready for' economic cooperation, but China desires to have the political "situation" in North China defined before precise steps pre taken to full that common need. Japan does not see the' necessity for this clarification but would proceed at once to enter into business agreements without the intrusion of political issues, There may be good ground for either point of view, but it seems to the detached observer that Japan is not doing herself justice if she thinks that the Gordian knot can be cut by the sword. Whether the reports from Nanking of an impending large-scale movement to engage the Japanese forces in combat will be justified by the event, may be left out of account for the moment, Let it be assumed that they are incorrect and that Japan will be able to consolidate her- regime in the North while the Government of China seeks by the best means in its power to reconcile its people to the new demonstration of aggression's capacity for dominance of Chinese soil. Will it be seriously argued that the prospect tions between Japan and China ha thereby been improved? If it be alleged that the Chinese Government has not been sufficiently alert to perceive the good intentions of Japan's more "moderate" policy and so has given a new handle for the Japanese militarists to discredit that policy, the question to be asked is whether a real diplomatic effort has been made to dispose of the difference in view on the process of economic.co-opera: tion, It may be true.that some Chinese spokesmen have been airily overstating the advances made by their Government and, to that extent, have given colour to the argument that forbearance has been mistaken by them for weakness, but does a great nation like Japan, in devising its policy, shiily-shaily fon such frivolous. pretexts? If a policy. be. seriously contemplated are not there means to see that suck: casual threats to its success. are relegated to their proper obscurity, Whatever criticism there may be of Nanking for the failure to grasp the urgency of the cris emerged on "Suly" 7, Japanese taxpayers on whom must now fall the burden of supporting a costly expeditionary force have reason to complain of the muddling of Sino-Japanese relations by their soldiers and statesmen, Not the least cause for complaint ies in the radical misconceptions of the situation forced upon them by official and semi-official pronouncements Tokyo. Their diplomacy has not been given a free hand. It has been hamstring by the militarists.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.