The Archive · 1939

Where America Stands

It is now perfectly clear why German representations on the subject of the recent speech by Mr. Harold L. Ickes, U.S. Secretary of the Interior, met with the reception it did at Washington, for, if the desired apology had been granted, it would have stultified the President in preparing his message to Congress which was delivered on Wednesday, It is true that the President referred to no particular nation, but the manner in which he posed the issue between democracies, and those nations adhering to an entirely different political philosophy permits of there being no misunderstanding as to where his references were directed. His remarks were almost as strong as those used by Mr. Ickes in his much-criticized Cleveland speech, and it is now made plain that whether Mr. Ickes was speaking with the Government's consent or not, he was interpreting what was really felt in Washington. If there were at any time doubt as to where the United States stood in the struggle between conflicting ideologies there can be none now, and while it would be idle to expect anything in the nature of a combination of the United States with the European democracies Mr. Roosevelt has definitely shown that the sympathies of his Government are with the latter. Three institutions, now as always indispensible to Americans, are being threatened in Europe, and Mr. Roosevelt sees a similar threat to them growing in the western hemisphere. They are religion, democracy and international good faith. Religion is being threatened by the modification in certain totalitarian states of freedom of belief and worship.

Democracy has been overthrown in some countries no matter what complexion the totalitarian doctrines may have assumed, while it has been made clear during the past few years that international good faith is at its lowest ebb, and, that endeavours to maintain it have been purely one-sided. In the putting of the American house in order is to be found the best means of combatting present-day tendencies. He has warned Congress that, though last year war was averted in Europe, peace has not yet been assured, though he apparently omitted to state upon whose shoulders responsibility for that failure must lie.

Perhaps) the most significant par of the message was the following We propose to do our share in protecting from storms from any quarter of this hemisphere an ideal of democratic government and peoples functioning together in mutual respect for peace.

This does not imply that the American republics will disassociate themselves from nations in another continent. It does pot mean that the Americans are against the rest of the world.

We stand on our historic offer to take counsel with all other nations to the end that aggression between them may terminate, the race for armaments cease, and commerce be renewed.

It is significant that the protection of the western continents is not a question which might arise when Europe might have been completely dominated by one form or other of totalitarianism, for it might very well prove to be the case that the American frontiers in such a struggle might be very much further east than the middle of the Atlantic, in the same manner as, according to a pronouncement by Earl Baldwin when Prime Minister, the frontiers of Great Britain extend as far as the Rhine. That need not necessarily imply that the United States would be prepared at some future time to send an expeditionary force to Europe as it did in the Great War, but it may mean that modification of the Neutrality Act will be necessary to permit the United States to give the European democracies that material aid which would be so necessary if they were to survive any general onslaught upon them. The policy as announced by President Roosevelt makes aggression in any part of the world a matter which the United States will not regard with unconcern. That is a warning which dictators cannot afford to ignore, for if in the ultimate result the forces of democracy came to be massed against those of totalitarianism there can be no question where the predominant strength would lie. There need be no fear about that particular aspect of the matter, for if there were a general attack upon demo-crocies they are even now in a position which would enable them to give a very good account of themselves. If it ever came to a clear cut struggle of that nature, fearful as it would be, there can be no doubt as to the outcome: it would be one completely distasteful to the totality It is nevertheless clear that Mr. evelt does not contemplate war as an immediate weapon of American policy. "Words may be futile," he says, "but war is not the only means of commanding respect for the opinions of mankind. There are many methods short of war designed to bring home to aggressor Governments the aggregate sentiments of our people." Clearer emphasis of the possibility of first resorting to economic means of impressing upon aggressors the necessity of mending their ways could not have been made. There are in the hands of the world's democracies weapons of enormous strength the use of which may have the desired effect. But their oper: tion requires that all the democracies of the world shall be united in their application, and be prepared to stand the results of such military acts as the ultimate desperation might very well engender. Hence the need for the increase in the armaments of the United States. The application of economic retaliation which this passage in the Pri sident's speech foreshadows in certain circumstances is fraught with the dangerous possibility that war might follow and it is just that eventuality which the United States, as also the other democracies will have to guard against. Preparations for a defence, which may not prove to be entirely passive, is one of the first essentials towards meeting a situation which shows no real improvement, and may in the not too distant future seriously deteriorate. Mr. Roosevelt has considerably strengthened the position of the other democracies of the world. He has pledged the loyalty of the United States to their common ideologies, and it is a feature of American history that its people are more willing to fight for a principle than for any mere question of material gain. It is in the spiritual quality of the President's utterances that the great strength is to be found. It is an encouragement to the rest of the democratic world, and a warning to those actuated by entirely different political ideals,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account