The Archive · 1938

ON CRITICISM

The lot of the critic is always a bitter one, whether he criticizes amateur or professional entertainment, art or literature or any of things which are susceptible to ism. The man who fails to find beauty in some of the creations of Mr.

Epstein, or in the vague meanderings of surrealism is, by the cognoscenti dubbed an ignorant lout, He who fails, on the other hand, to run with the common herd is classed as a poseur, and so, whichever way he leans, the critic is always in for trouble. This journal's critic who attended the performance of "The Sleeping Beauty" by the Russian Ballet has been taken to task for not mentioning the dancing of two of the members of the cast, and for using a quarter of the space at his disposal for "irrelevant criticism" of the orchestra, The writer of the letter was enthusiastic over the production and felt that those taking part in it had been hardly done by, and hurried to their defence, The critic replies in to-day's issue and gives his reason for omitting reference to the two dancers whom Mr, Richard Price so warmly commends. He did not find the dance.so perfect as is contended, and preferred, where he was unable to give commendation, not to say anything at all. He could' have, had he wanted to, pointed out the fault and drawn attention to it. That might have been the better course, in view of the fact that there were other performances at which amendment could be made, To have done so would have rendered the Ballet a service, but might ion the other hand have given his own critic further ground for attack. That, of course, should not, and probably did not influence him in the action he took, though possibly the sentiment of kindness led: him to criticize by omission, which is generally a quite effective method, though it has the disadvantage that the artist concerned may not realize the fault which deprived him of commendation.

In a place like Shanghai the critic has a more difficult task than he has in such cities as London and New York, Paris or Berlin.

He is known generally to a much larger proportion of the readers of this journal than would be the case where he serving a newspaper in any of the metropolis mentioned. There is, consequently, about his writing a quality of personality which is absent elsewhere. That should not deter him from frankness, it is true, but there is very much in the fact that he has to live with the people: he criticizes, and has, occasionally, to walk like the cat—circumspectly. That is more particularly the case when an amateur performance is under consideration. It is very difficult for an amateur having been criticized on the first performance to take the stage on the second and ensuing nights as if nothing had happened. He or she feels that the whole of the audience realizes what has happened, and is looking on with greater intentness than if he or she had not been criticized. A greater degree of self-con-Ciousness is induced, greater nervousness, for it is only the professional that can easily withstand the buffets of reviewers with that equanimity which comes of long experience and the knowledge that after all acting means a livelihood. He has got to accept criticism and like it, whether he does or not. The members of the Russian Ballet may be considered to be professionals, and while this journal's critic was most moderate in what he said, they cannot complain if they are not always "buttered up" as some people seem to think they should be. That raises the question as to whether amateurs and professionals should be handled differently when reviews of their performances are being written. On that there is a lasting and considerable difference of opinion. The proponents of the doctrine that, because both are taking the public's money, there is really no difference in the standards to be applied have much to support their view. It should not, however, be accepted with too much readiness, There is a great difference between the amateur and the professional, The former plays as a hobby, does not, and cannot be expected to give all the time and study to his part which is expected of the professional. The public supporting amateur theatricals fully realize that, and, when they reserve seats for such performances, are under no misapprehension. They are going to see an amateur show, and, consequently, fully realize what they have to expect, They are, naturally, not likely to be hypercritical, and, if they are not, there is no reason why the critic should adopt any different attitude. Of recent years amateur theatrical productions in Shanghai have reached a very high standard. There are some who aver that the A.D.C's recent performance came very close to the play as seen in London. High praise indeed, but probably inspired by just that toleration which this journal argues should be applied to amateur efforts. On the other hand, were canons of professional criticism applied to amateur productions, how often could it be said that they better the efforts of the second raters in the profession? Not very often, though without exaggeration, it may be said that many recent performances have been just as good. With regard to the Russian professionals appearing in Shanghai the same principles can be held to apply. The public knows who they are, the resources at their disposal, the talent in their ranks, and, realizing all this, knows just about what sort of performance to expect at their hands. They are; consequently, not deceived if the newspaper critics show that same moderation towards them that they show to the amateur. Different considerations arise when an unknown professional company—of which Shanghai has seen so few in recent years—comes to town. The newspaper reviewer is expected to tell the public what sort of performance it gives, whether it provides entertainment sufficiently good to justify the outlay upon tickets. Here the public does not know all the circumstances and has to depend upon the newspapers in the first instance. In to-day's issue the critic shows that he is quite able to look after himself, and he may rest assured ne this journal has complete confidence in

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account