The Archive · 1938

A REJOINDER

The report appearing in this journal concerning the shooting of a Chinese by a Japanese sentry on Keswick Road was attacked Cly the Japanese spokesman yesterday morning at the Press Conference, according to Domei. The spokesman is reported to "have taken strong exception to this journal's statement that "a foreigner who visited the scene shortly after the incident stated that no roll of copper wire was to be seen in the neighbourhood, and to have added "This is not the first time that this newspaper has sacrificed the truth in favour of national interests." It is necessary that the attention of the Japanese spokesman, who so facilely accuses this journal of prevarication, to the fact that it published two accounts of the incident—one that resulted from its own it quiries and the other supplied to it by Japanese sources. There are material differences between the two, but in fairness to the Japanese the two accounts were published. The spokesman produced a photograph of a roll of wire near some barbed wire entanglements as proof that the Chinese was indeed doing what the Japanese alleged. But it has to be pointed out that such a photograph proves nothing except that it is a picture of a roll of wire, no details being given of when, where, and in what circumstances it was taken, and, in the absence of suck details, the evidential value of the picture mi be regarded as exceedingly small. The Japanese version claims that the sentry shot the Chinese dead; the information in the possession of this journal is that he died three hours later in hospital. If with regard to the roll of copper wire Japanese information is no more ae. curate than as to whether the Chinese was shot dead or not, this journal must be forgiven if it prefers to accept the story as shown by its Own investigation in preference to that given irom Japanese sources. Unlike the Japanese spokesman this journal does not suggest for One moment that national interests dictate the manifest inaccuracies in the Japanese account of the matter, nor that the Japanese*have been guilty of wilful tergiversation, though it takes the liberty to express doubts as to whether the Japanese spokesman was as fully informed on the subject, as he should. have been, before making such a charge,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account