President Roosevelt's forthcoming message io the U.S. Congress on the subject of America's national defence is giving rise to a-great deal of speculation. His letter to Rear Admiral R.B. Belknap has considerable significance, and may serve as an indication of the lines the President will take in his niessage. As was only to be expected, Representative Hamilton Fish has again brought up the question of naval limitation, and has announced his intention of proposing an amendment to the Navy Department's Appropriation Bill, authorizing and requesting the President to convoke a world naval conference, It is quite likely that, though the President will gain ample support for his national defence scheme, some such amendment will be attached to the Bill, for there would be nothing illogical in so doing. The world is at present engaged in a mad scramble to build bigger and better armaments, The same competition which preceded the Great War and which was again noticed at its conclusion before the Washington Conference was convened, is again being witnessed. It was arrested in 1922 for a decade and a half and it is only as a result of the collapse of the London Conference that a resumption of the naval armament race has occurred, Mr.
Fish seeks to lay the blame for that failure upon the "militarists and admirals." He is not entirely just in doing so, for though their expert advice had to be taken on all points there is little doubt that political considerations played an important part in bringing about the disastrous collapse. It will be remembered that, at the London Conference, Japan proposed a common upper limit of naval tonnage, which in order to secure real disarmament, should be placed at as low a level as possible. Her proposals did not receive the support of the delegations of other nations and on January 15, 1935, she withdrew her representatives. Commenting on the withdrawal the Japanese Prime Minister the next day said he did not believe a naval race would be begun, but warned the nation to be prepared for any eventuality, while the Foreign Minister said Japanese still desired to conclude minor agreements and to subscribe to a joint declaration against a naval race.
Bad as the situation was following the collapse of the London Conference, matters became speedily warse, with developments in the European situation which forced upon Britain the realization of the very unpleasant fact that the good example in the reduction of armaments which she had sought to set the rest of the world, had not only failed to have that effect, but had deprived her voice of much of its former authority. It was in that year, then, that the five-year-plan for the rehabilitation of British defences was undertaken, and Britain is again rapidly reaching the position from which she ought never to have receded, Other countries were taking advantage of the failure to reach a common understanding and it was imperative for Great Britain to see that her forces were maintained at an adequate strength to meet all emergencies. She did not start the naval race: by the time she announced her decision it had already commenced and she could not afford to allow herself to be left behind. The prospects of success at another naval conference do not appear particularly bright. The Japanese attitude has been perfectly well defined, and, as in 1936, so in any future conference it may be expected that Japan's requirements will be exactly the same and her policy just as definite. In those circumstances unless the other great Powers were inclined to grant her desires no success could possibly attend the holding of such negotiations. That would now mean the adoption of the common upper limit of naval tonnage, and that limit instead of being lower as Japan. then wished, would have to be higher in view of all that has transpired since 1936 and the increased building which has been in progress ever since.
Rear Admiral Kiyoshi Noda, Chief of the Japanese Navy's Information Bureau, makes the point perfectly clear in the statement which was published yesterday. Japan, he said, will not begin and will not take place in any naval armament race and is still ready to participate in a naval limitation conference provided she is assured the policy of non-menace and non-aggression, and the principle of a common upper limit with Britain and America will be seriously considered. That amounts to naval parity which neither Great Britain or the United States are prepared to concede. Japan endeavouring to build up to parity and these two nations determined to maintain the ratio, with Italy proposing to embark upon an extensive strengthening of her fleets, have in fact brought about just that race which it was so desirable to avoid.
The latest news from the United States is that Navy officials are considering a rearmament plan to include an undetermined number of the most powerful battleships in the world, exceeding 40,000 tons and equipped with 18-inch guns. This would involve the abandonment of the London Naval Treaty, limitations by the United States and would 82 serve notice on the world that America was meeting the challenge seen in the new Japanese construction which, it is alleged, include two battleships of 45,000 tons. Japanese action in adopting this policy has undoubtedly done much to create anxiety and to contribute to the determination of other countries that they will not be left behind in the matter of naval construction. Great Britain and the United States can be confidently expected to match tonnage with tonnage and guns with guns, and, when it comes to paying for it, both of them are better fitted to do so than is Japan, That the whole thing is madness is unhappily true. But then there is so much madness extant in the world at the present moment that a little more seems to matter little either way. If Mr. Hamilton Fish's suggestion is embodied in the Navy Appropriation Bill President Roosevelt will most probably act upon it, but conditions being what they are, it would seem that any attempt to stem this insane*expenditure is doomed to failure unless Japan gets what she wants.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.