The Archive · 1940

SOME AFTERTHOUGHTS

One of the immediate effects of the negotiation of peace between Finland and Russia, has been on the one hand a certain amount of recrimination, and on the other a degree of protest which in the circumstances is not without justification. Condemnation: of Norway and Sweden is not wholly to be justified, and it is to be hoped that it will soon cease as the facts of the matter come to be more clearly appreciated. It is true that, until a very short while ago, the Scandinavian countries, proud in their independence ana the peace they have enjoyed for so long a time, were, internationally speaking, rugged individualists. There was general acceptance of the belief that so long as they maintained forces sufficient for little more than policing purposes, and stuck carefully to the practice of minding their own^business, they were in no danger whatever of aggression. The first motion to realize the opposite was Finland, whose experiences during the war of freedom led its Government to understand that those liberties, so dearly won, could only be preserved so long as it was in a position to defend them, and it was the full comprehension of the menace which the Soviet always continued to be that led to the construction of the Mannerheim Line and the maintenance of a system of military training which permitted the Finns to save what they have out of the general débâcle which threatened them. The same was not the case with Norway and Sweden. Without being too critical,—and who should be in the light of the unprecedented situation with which their Governments were confronted?—it may be safely said that they never fully appreciated the dangers which were created by the infamous Russo-German pact of August last, and it is only now that they have been brought to a complete realization of the fact that their independence is good only for just so long as they are prepared to defend it. Hence the talk now of a defensive alliance between Finland, Sweden and Norway. Finland by consenting to consider the Russian overtures for peace has gained a breathing space for the whole of Scandinavia, allowing it to put its house in order and prepare against the further aggression which it has every reason to expect.

The strategic gains which the Russians have obtained in this peace with Finland constitute a direct threat to both Norway and Sweden, and it would be the height of credulity to believe that these requirements were made on Finland without some idea of utilizing the benefits, which these new dispositions confer upon the Soviet, in any attempt to invade either Norway, or Sweden, or both. Thus it will be seen that manifest peril has changed the Scandinavian nations from their rugged individualism. They are now animated with a desire to take steps for their common defence. It is only to be hoped that it is not now too late. One other aspect of the aftermath of the Finnish-Russian peace is the bombastic claims which have been put forward by German quarters, and others friendly to them, that this peace constitutes a direct setback to the cause of the Allies, and that their position vis-à-vis of Turkey is consequently considerably weakened. Both claims can be tested very simply.

In what way is the Allied position worse now than it was before the invasion of Finland commenced? The answer is obvious,—in no way. The Allies are still at war with Germany which has achieved no success of any importance; they have continued to make headway in their blockade of Germany, and have successfully maintained their position against the unrestricted undersea warfare which Germany has been carrying on all along. The position has changed in no material particular, and so far as Europe is concerned the Allies are exactly where they were before the Finnish-Russian hostilities commenced. Much has been made of the fact that the Allies were unable to go to the aid of the Finns in time. It is now known that they were not asked to, and that all the Finns informally inquired of them was whether a force of 30,000 men could be available in May. Events have prevented that question being answered. The situation is not the same in the Near East. Imposing forces are already on the spot ready to go to the assistance of Turkey in the event of Russian aggression. Turkey can be assisted and there is neither geographical position, nor the possibility of enemy action to prevent it. The German suggestion, therefore, that the Allies have been weakened by the developments in Finland is but another instance of that type of wishful thinking into which the vagaries of the bunch of eccentrics ruling Germany have lulled the people.

Indeed it may without exaggeration be stated that the peace has proved of benefit to the Allies. A continuance of the war would have meant that they would have sought to honour their undertakings to Finland, over sea routes 2,500 miles in length. Along them at least 100,000 and probably more men would have had to be transported, and maintained once they were landed, as expansive and as tempting a target as the German submarine fleet could ever hope to have presented to them. They have been relieved of that heavy responsibility, and it is consequently apparent that, through the disappearance of the necessity to maintain hostilities on a front so difficult of access, the Allies instead of finding their position worse realize it is very much better than it might have been. There is but one other thought upon this peace which has been reached. Whether it is lasting or not only the future will tell. The terms imposed upon Finland, iniquitous as they are, would undoubtedly have been heavier had Moscow not desired to stop fighting which was costing the Soviet so heavily. Had the Russian forces had the walk-over, which they hoped copying the German blitzkrieg would give them, the Finns would undoubtedly have received the benefits of the same sort of peace as that which the Reich in its benevolence is bestowing upon Czechoslovakia and Poland, the peace of the rubber truncheon, the concentration camp and all those other precious balms which the brutal ingenuity of the Nazis has invented for its victims. That the Finns have, at any rate for the moment, escaped. An opportunity has been given the Scandinavian countries to prepare against those ominous threats which Russo-German ce-operation in the Finnish struggle has made so dreadfully apparent. The Allies have lost nothing, save in the perfervid imaginations of their ill-wishers. Russia has rounded out her control of the Baltic Sea, which is no longer a domain pre-eminently German, and Herr Hitler still waits for the wonderful amount of supplies which he hoped his surrender to the Bolsheviks would give him.

The Reduced Estimates In recent communiques which have been issued by the Shanghai Municipal Council something approaching a polemic note is to be noticed, as apart from rational explanation, and the one which was issued yesterday on the subject of the very substantial reductions in the preliminary estimates for next year proves to be no exception. It is very right for the Council to seek to defend itself when criticised, but there is a danger that, if criticism is anticipated in this manner, it may stimulate certain types of mind to believe that "the lady doth protest too much." That, however, en passant. It is gratifying to learn from the communique, which appears in another column, that the greatest possible attention has been paid to the task of keeping municipal expenditure down to the minimum, and the manner in which preliminary estimates have been cut suggests that this has been done effectively. It is to be hoped not too effectively. Over $2,000,000 was cut out of the estimates, with the result that the inevitable increases have been kept well within reasonable proportions. It is, nevertheless, an importtant fact to remember that while this has been effected on one hand, the rising price of foodstuffs has recently necessitated a further provision in the estimate of over $1,500,000. Of those fifteen lakhs six represent the cost of feeding prisoners in the jail, a luxury with which Shanghai could very well have dispensed when it was obliged to surrender the Mixed Court. It is very much of an anomaly that the International Settlement should be burdened with the maintenance of persons offending against the laws of China, and, while there were very good reasons why the decision to do so was taken at the time it was, it is suggested that those conditions no longer prevail and that as soon as possible the jail should be handed over to the Chinese, Despite increases the Municipal orchestra, and band have been budgeted for within the authorized $200,000, but that has been done by the expedient of applying the moneys in the Reserve Fund maintained for the betterment of the orchestra and to meet unforeseen circumstances. It appears to be justified under the latter heading. It is to be expected that the controversy regarding the retention of the orchestra—an old hardy annual,—will be fought with greater bitterness than ever before. The argument that the Orchestra is very much of a luxury, something which has always been agreed upon, has in view of the slashing reductions which have been made, greater cogency than ever before. It is one of the amenities as opposed to necessaries to which the Council refers in its communique, and it is for the ratepayers to decide whether they want it or not. No official statement has been made one way or the other, and it is not expected that any will be made. The matter rests entirely in the hands of the ratepayers who may be expected to give the matter just about as much consideration this year as they have done in the past, Pot and Kettle The Nazi press have seized upon the murder of Sir Michael O'Dwyer, and the wounding of three others by an Indian in London, on Wednesday, with high glee, claiming it to be in revenge for the alleged "massacre" at Amritsar in April, 1919. Murder must, of course mean little or nothing to the gentry who have been engaged in it, wholesale, for years past, or they may even glorify it. The facts of the alleged "massacre" are well known. On April 11 five Europeans were murdered in Amritsar, when the rioters looted and fired the banks, the bodies of the Europeans in the National Bank of India being burnt beyond recognition. On April 13 the mob defied a proclamati forbidding meetings, and, after due warning, were fired on, there being 200 killed and wounded. Sir Michael was Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab at the time, but was not on the scene when the order to fire was given. His murder in London may have been for revenge or it may not. It ill becomes the Nazis to rake up a story out of which the British emerged with very considerable credit, for they would be better employed examining their own very murky record. There was a time when it was held that the Germans were unfit to be colonize ers in charge of natives in Africa because of their treatment of the Herreros, who, it will be remembered, were virtually exterminated. That attitude with the passage of time was modified until, as late as 1938, the old theory of the "colonial guilt" of Germany was admitted to be a lie. That may have been due in more respects than one to a real desire to come to some better understanding with Germany, for the fact remains that, whether it was the direct result of German action or inaction the Hereros nearly suffered extinction. The events of the past two years, the treatment of the Czechs and latterly of the Poles is ample evidence to support the view that the Nazis are not fit persons to have government over subjected peoples, and though it could not be suggested for one moment that the old Herrero story should be revived, it is as well to remember that the German treatment of the Jews justifies the opinion that in the old African reproach the smoke which was so noticeable undoubtedly came from a fire.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account