The Archive · 1938

INQUEST ON W. J. € SHORPEE Before Mr. C. H. Haines, Coroner

(Verdict of accidental death)

The possibility that Mr. W. J. C. Shoppe fell from a higher floor in the Broadway Mansions than the second floor was mentioned by Mr.

Haines, Coroner," at the concussion of Feb, 2 hearing of the inquest on Mr. Shoppe, which was adjourned until 1030-am. on Jan. 4. Mr, Haines expressed the belief that further medical evidence might dispose of the theory that he had fallen {from the second floor. "There is an. interval of a quarter of an hour from the time Mr. Shoppe left the ground floor fo the time when his eries were Before giving his verdict, Mr, Haines said evidence was, clear that deceased went to the Broadway Mansions at 445 pin, entering the central part from the east wing, making inquiries about his flat. After that, his movements were not known. Definite statements were made that barriers in front of the lift shafts were in place both before and after the fall.

was considered -to be extremely probable that the deceased had walk ed from the swing door on the second floor into the opening. It wns, however, merely a theory which was shaken by Dr. Gauntiett's evidence. There was not the slightest ground for suspecting suicide. There was also no. suggestion of foul play. Mr. Haines therefore gave the above verdict which he considered to be general heard", Mr. Haines declared, "and this is not explained by the evidence up to this point."

Mr. Haines expressed his intention of calling Dr. E G. Gauntlett, who previously gave medical evidence Which tended to. show that Mtr.

Shoppee had fallen from the second oer.

Bvidenco was given on Feb, 2 by James Arthur Mason, employed as engineer jo Broadway Mansions, who stated that after showing a Mr. Morris to an apartment on the second floor, he heard screams, but it was dimeult to tell where they came from. This was about 5 pin. Witness and Mr.

Howard, a previous witness, took the lift to the ground floor. Here they picked up the number one fitter, and ascended to the seventh floor. There, they heard more cries, and went down to apartment 22, on the second floor. Attempting to trace the direction from which the eries came, the three men walked down to the first floor, and the Number One Atter shouted, "There is some one in the Tet share".

They then went round to the-back of the building, where the service lift was. situated, "and found it raised about four feet from the ground. With. the aid of torches, they could see someone lying in the lift well. They lifted Mr. Shoppe up on to the floor, and he complained that his arm was broken. Witness assured him that his, arm was not broken, and he then complained about pain in his right eve.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account