The Archive · 1939

Dispute Over Family Name

Shanghai, June 14.

Stating that the defendant firm, desiring to give its name a foreign aspect, had unfortunately chosen their family name, Dr. Aurel Gouda and his brother M. Charles Henry Gouda appeared os plaintiffs in the First Special District Court yester action against the Gondo Trad Chinese firm dealing in export and import business at 9B Central Arcade, 119 Nanking Road.

Represented by AL Paull Premet, plaintiff alleged that the Chinese tame of the firm was "Kong Dah" Dut that they appeared as "The Gouda Trading Ca." both in the Hong List and the Telephone directory. Through their attorney they contended that according to the foreign custom well as Chinese law (Art. 19 of the Chinese Civil Code) anyone is the Proprietor of his family name and tone is entitled to use it.

'M. Premet contended that anyone who borrowed another person's name infringed the right to the use of the name and that the real owner could apply to the court for an order stop ping such an abuse, In this case, he said, the Chinese characters expressing Kong Dah could not be translated as Gouda and owing to the liberal [professions of plaintifs—one was a Goctor and the other an architect— their name and reputation might be seriously damaged.

Stating that the public might think that the plaintiffs carried on another business they asked for an order restraining the defendants from using the name "Gonds," the erasing of the name from the Hong List and Telephone directory, and $1 damages and costs, The defendants contended that there was no actual similarity between a business such as their own and that of the plaintiffs. Furthermore, they stated that anyone could use the name "Gonds" and they quoted examples where several firms were using the same name. After hearing the arguments the court invited the parties {0 try to reach a compromise. This was declared impossible and the hearing was then adjourned.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account