The Archive · 1939

TWO AGREEMENTS

Today two pacts to be signed by France, and Turkey not only should serve to remove some of the causes of mutual irritation in the eastern Mediterranean, but should also serve to tighten up the anti-aggression block, for on the one hand France returns the Sanjak of Alexandretta to Turkey, and on the other, those two countries enter into a mutual assistance pact similar to that which has already been reached between Great Britain and Turkey. The Turks have consistently laid claim to Alexandretta in the north of Syria, very close to the Turkish borders, and under the terms on which the French had announced the forthcoming surrender of the mandate for Syria, the Alexandretta area would have become an autonomous area, büt still outside the Turkish area. Throughout last year there was a tenseness in the Sanjak which occupied the first place in the relations between France and Syria, and in fact far exceeded in importance the question of the unratified treaty between those two countries. The trouble arose out of the mixed character of the population in which it is claimed that no nationality has a majority, though it is admitted that the Turks represent the largest minority. A settlement was reached which visualized the formation of an auto-nomeus administration nominally within the framework of the Syrian state, and this settlement was confirmed in an agreement signed by France, as the protector of Syria, and the Turkish Government, on July 4, 1938, as a result of which the preponderating influence of the Turks in the Sanjak, or Hatay, as it was henceforth to be known, was acknowledged. This arrangement was not particularly satisfactory to Damascus, where n interests had been sacrificed, and it is stated that the Syrian Government only accepted the arrangement under the duress of Turkish threats., Incidentally it may be mentioned that it was in connection with this dispute that the League of Nations met with another of those rebuffs to which by now it must be accustomed.

The League, with the approval of the French, and the Turks, sent out a Commission to supervise elections upon which a decision was to be based, but which in fact never took place, and upon the demand of the Turks the Commission was withdrawn. The cause of this discourtesy, to use no stronger term, was the promise which it was alleged had been given in advance by the French that the elections would result in a Turkish majority in the Assembly of the new republic of Hatay, and the subsequent discovery that it would be impossible to fulfil this promise if a totally free election were to be held. Obviously this would have been the case, for as has already been pointed out the Turks were not in the majority, but merely formed the largest minority of the population of the Sanjak. After a period of very considerable disturbance during which there was a number of casualties and French and Turkish troops had to be drafted into the district, and even a certain amount of friction between the two Powers, a settlement, which was part of a larger one between France and Turkey formally ack-knowledged the preponderance of Turkish interests in Hatay without, however, recognizing that Turkey had any territorial claim. Upon signature of this agreement a legislative body was appointed in which the Turks were given a majority, and that body at once resolved that Hatay was a republican state with an effective Turkish majority. The new agreement under which France gives up Hatay to Turkey seems to be the logical development of the events of last year, and may very well lead to a better state of affairs between Syria and Turkey, providing the former accepts an arrangement which quite obviously does not fulfil its own ambitions. The treaty pledges Turkey to respect French moral and material interests within the Sanjak and to protect all minorities there. Turkey further agrees to abandon any other territorial claims upon Syria and to refrain from all propaganda in that country.

On the face of it this latest agreement seems the best that could be done in the circumstances, and appears to be the only possible development following the events of recent years. It means that the territorial integrity of the Sanjak, which was guaranteed by the Franco-Turkish treaty of 1937 is abandoned as also the constitution which the League of Nations was to confer upon it last November. By that the Sanjak was to have been created a distinct international unit with full independence in internal affairs while its foreign affairs were to be dealt with by Syria. That never came into effect, for on September 2, 1938, the Sanjak became the Hatay Republic under the Turkish flag. What has happened then is merely that France and Turkey have regularized a position which has been in existence since September of last year, and, so long as this is acceptable to the Syrian Government, there should be bright prospects for the restoration of peace in that particularly disturbed portion of the eastern Mediterranean littoral. The conclusion of the Franco-Turkish mutual assistance pact which has been assisted by the solution of the Sanjak issue is another move in the direction of strengthening those. Powers who are opposed to aggression, such as it is believed is contemplated by the dictator states, and when the British-Soviet negotiations are brought to a successful conclusion, as it is hoped they will be, the structure which Mr. Chamberlain has sought to erect since his disillusionment will have been completed. That will be all to the good, and if in reaching so important an objective the Sanjak has had to be treated in a manner which was not originally contemplated, the complexity of the question of minorities justifies the steps which have been taken.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account