The Archive · 1938

Clash of Expert Opinion

Standing today before his colleagues of the British Association, holding the fragments of the skull with hands which shook a little, he described the ancient working floor where he had excavated and the stage of human development revealed by his discovery.

He was not, however, satisfied with the conclusions of the experts about the age of the fossil, to which he was inclined to assign an even greater antiquity.

This drew from Sir Arthur Keith For this reason the routine disinfection of articles of furniture, of walls and floors, has already been largely given up as useless by many public health authorities, since it is not from these that pathogenic organisms—even if they may lurk upon them for a brief period—can spring up and infect chance users or passers-by. And the results have gone to confirm earlier observations in America—some of them extending pack for thirty years—where the en-ire abandonment in certain towns of routine domestic disinfection of this sort in cases of diphtheria was followed by no greater a recurrence rate amongst contacts and no greater a recurrence rate than that in towns where full domestic disinfection was still being carried on.

Fumigation or Spraying Useless Further, it was found that, if specially planted colonies of pathogenic organisms were lodged on walls and floors, the usual methods of furni gation or spraying with ordinary disinfectants were not in fact capable of destroying them—or at any rate in a materially shorter time than that in which their death or impotence would normally have occurred. It is true, of course, that at any one moment—especially in urban surroundings—it may be possible to recover a few non-pathogenic organi and even an occasional pathogenic organism from almost any article in daily use, but that, in any ordinary handling of such an article, these are a source of acute infection is now a conception that is generally obsolete except perhaps, to some extent, in the popular imagination. And even in the out-patient departments and wards of most general and fever hospitals regular simple cleansing by soap, water, scrubbing and polish has become the common—and is con monly regarded-as a. sulficient—procedure.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account